[Durgical](https://durgical.com/en/) › [DurgiPedia](https://durgical.com/en/durgipedia/) › [Clinical skills](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/) › [OSCE stations](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/areas/stations/) › Closed-loop communication, the two-challenge rule and CUS

# Closed-loop communication, the two-challenge rule and CUS

- OSCE station

An order is not given until it has been repeated back. Closed loops and plain words to stop the line keep messages from vanishing in a noisy room.

Updated Nov 19, 2026

## Key points

- Call-out: critical information said aloud to the whole team at once.
- Closed loop: request to a named person, check-back by the receiver, confirmation by the sender, report when done.
- Requests go to named people; «someone…» is heard by nobody.
- Two-challenge rule: voice a concern at least twice; if still ignored, take stronger action and escalate.
- CUS: «I am concerned», «I am uncomfortable», «This is a safety issue»; the last means stop and reassess.

On this page

- The basics Key points
- What it is
- How to think about it
- What is assessed
- How to do it (and why)
- The communication tools: when to use each and what the listener does
- Mistakes that cost marks
- Self-check list
- Common traps
- Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

- Study Test yourself

- Connections Connections

## What it is

Closed-loop communication makes sure that a message has arrived as it was meant. It has three parts: the sender gives a call-out or verbal order to a named person, the receiver repeats it back (check-back), and the sender confirms or corrects it, which closes the loop; in practice the receiver also reports when the task is done. In [TeamSTEPPS](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/teamwork-in-clinical-care-roles-a-shared-mental-model-and-speaking-up/), a call-out tells critical information to the whole team at once, and a check-back confirms that information was understood as intended. Requests go to people by name or role, because a request made to the room has no owner: WHO's advice to students is to delegate tasks to people, not to the air. When a concern is ignored, the two-challenge rule asks the team member to voice it at least twice; if it is still not addressed, they take stronger action and escalate up the chain of command. CUS is a set of escalating assertive statements, «I am concerned», «I am uncomfortable», «This is a safety issue», and the last phrase is a signal to stop and reassess. The DESC script (describe, express, specify, consequences) is used later to resolve the conflict. WHO recommends [read-back](https://durgical.com/en/epidemiology/communication-language-and-equity-in-patient-safety/) of critical information at hand-overs, and in Colombia MinSalud's patient safety package on communication proposes measuring how often verbal orders are repeated aloud by the receiver and written in the record.

## How to think about it

Treat every instruction like throwing a ball in a crowd: call the catcher's name before you throw, wait for them to shout back what they caught, nod, and expect a shout when it lands. If you see a ball heading for the patient and nobody reacts, raise your voice in fixed steps, concerned, uncomfortable, safety issue, until the game stops.

## What is assessed

- Gets the receiver's attention by name or role, with eye contact, before giving a task.
- Gives one clear instruction at a time with its key details (what, which patient, which route).
- The receiver repeats the instruction before acting, and the sender confirms or corrects it.
- The receiver reports aloud when the task is done.
- Concerns are stated with facts and a proposed action, and repeated if not acknowledged.
- Escalation words are used at the right level, and the leader responds by pausing to reassess.

## How to do it (and why)

- Get the person's attention by name or role — a directed request has one owner.
- Give one clear instruction with its key details — short messages survive noise.
- The receiver repeats it back in full — mishearing shows here, before it reaches the patient.
- The sender confirms («Correct») or corrects — the loop is closed only on confirmation.
- The receiver reports when the task is done — the leader can tick it off and move on.
- If you see a risk, state it with facts and a proposal — «Saturation is falling, I suggest we check the tube» is hard to ignore.
- If it is ignored, say it again, rephrased (the second challenge) — the first may simply not have been heard.
- If it is still ignored, use the CUS words and escalate up the chain of command — a safety issue stops the line.

## The communication tools: when to use each and what the listener does

| Tool | When | What you say | What the listener does |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Call-out | A critical finding everyone needs | «No pulse!» or «Saturation falling!» | Everyone updates their picture of the patient |
| Directed request | Assigning any task | «Luis, please call the blood bank» | The named person checks back and acts |
| Check-back | Every order and every critical value | The receiver repeats the order in full | The sender confirms or corrects |
| Two-challenge rule | A concern is ignored | The same concern, at least twice | The leader acknowledges it and responds |
| CUS | A safety concern that must stop the action | «I am concerned… uncomfortable… this is a safety issue» | Stop and reassess |
| DESC script | Resolving a conflict afterwards | Describe, express, specify, consequences | Agree on a way forward |

## Mistakes that cost marks

- Orders shouted to the room with no name: two people do the task, or nobody does.
- Answering «OK» instead of repeating the order: «OK» confirms hearing, not content.
- A sender who does not listen to the check-back, so a wrong repeat goes through.
- Hinting («Are you sure about that?») when a clear statement is needed.
- Dropping a concern after one try because the senior looked busy.

## Self-check list

- Did I name the person before each request?
- Did I give one instruction at a time?
- Did every receiver repeat the instruction back?
- Did I confirm or correct each check-back?
- Was completion of each task reported?
- Did I state concerns with facts and a proposal?
- Did I repeat an unheard concern and escalate when needed?

## Common traps

- **Saying «OK» closes the loop**: only repeating the content shows what was understood; «OK» shows that something was heard
- **An order shouted to the room reaches everyone**: a request without a name spreads responsibility until nobody owns it
- **The two-challenge rule means ask twice, then accept**: if the concern is still not addressed, take stronger action and escalate
- **CUS is for nurses talking to doctors**: anyone may use it, including a junior doctor with a consultant or a senior with a junior
- **Closed loops are only for emergencies**: verbal orders and critical results need a read-back at any time

## Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

## During an arrest the leader says «Can someone get the defibrillator?» and nobody moves. Why, and how should it be said?

A request to the room has no owner. Name a person: «Carla, bring the defibrillator, please», wait for «Bringing the defibrillator», and expect a report when it arrives.

## What are the steps of closed-loop communication?

A call-out or order to a named person, a check-back in which the receiver repeats it, confirmation by the sender, and a report from the receiver when the task is done.

## A scrub nurse twice tells the surgeon that the swab count is wrong, and the surgeon starts to close. What should the nurse do next?

Use CUS: «This is a safety issue» means stop. The concern has been ignored twice, so the two-challenge rule calls for stronger action: escalate up the chain of command before closure.

## Why is a check-back safer than answering «Understood»?

Repeating the content exposes mishearing, such as the wrong drug, patient or route, before anyone acts; «Understood» only shows that something was heard.

[Add to my cards (4)](https://durgical.app/estudiar/?add=/en/clinical-skills/closed-loop-communication-the-two-challenge-rule-and-cus/)

## Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

- [Delegation and the care team: professional nurses, nursing auxiliaries and students](https://durgical.com/en/nursing/delegation-and-the-care-team-professional-nurses-nursing-auxiliaries-and-student/)
- [Handoff and SBAR communication](https://durgical.com/en/nursing/handoff-and-sbar-communication/)

## Connections

## Related 4

- [Teamwork in clinical care: roles, a shared mental model and speaking up](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/teamwork-in-clinical-care-roles-a-shared-mental-model-and-speaking-up/)
- [Crisis resource management (CRM): the principles for a team in an emergency](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/crisis-resource-management-the-principles-for-a-team-in-an-emergency/)
- [Doctor-to-doctor handover at shift change: I-PASS and the receiver's role](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/doctor-to-doctor-handover-at-shift-change-i-pass-and-the-receiver-s-role/)
- [The emergency (ABCDE) station](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/the-emergency-station/)

[← All clinical skills](https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/)

Educational content; it does not replace supervised hands-on training, your institution's protocols or a prescriber's order. A procedure is learnt with a teacher and done only once you are trained to do it.

Sources: [Learning to Speak Up for Patient Safety: Interprofessional Scenarios for Training Future Healthcare Professionals](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7325460/) (Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development (PMC), 2020); [Optimizing Teamwork in the Operating Room: A Scoping Review of Actionable Teamwork Strategies](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11180536/) (Cureus (PMC), 2024); [Patient Safety Curriculum Guide: Multi-professional Edition. Topic 4, Being an effective team player (teaching slides)](https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/patient-safety/curriculum-guide/resources/ps-curr-teach-guides/topic-04_being-an-effective-team-player_teaching-slides.pdf) (World Health Organization, 2011); [Gestionar y desarrollar la adecuada comunicación entre las personas que atienden y cuidan a los pacientes (paquete instruccional, versión 2.0)](https://www.minsalud.gov.co/sites/rid/Lists/BibliotecaDigital/RIDE/DE/CA/Guia-estrategia-de-comunicacion.pdf) (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social de Colombia, 2015); [Communication During Patient Hand-Overs (Patient Safety Solutions, vol. 1, solution 3)](https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/patient-safety/patient-safety-solutions/ps-solution3-communication-during-patient-handovers.pdf) (World Health Organization, WHO Collaborating Centre for Patient Safety Solutions, 2007).

## **Spotted a mistake?** We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it. Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.

---
Source: https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/closed-loop-communication-the-two-challenge-rule-and-cus/
License: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Cite as: DurgiPedia (durgical.com), https://durgical.com/en/clinical-skills/closed-loop-communication-the-two-challenge-rule-and-cus/
