Durgical
EN
Open the app

Decision analysis and decision trees

  • Concept

When the best choice depends on chances and on what each outcome is worth, a decision tree lays the options out and adds them up so they can be compared.

Updated

What it is

Decision analysis models a choice explicitly: options start at a decision node, uncertain events branch at chance nodes with probabilities, and each path ends in an outcome with a value (utility). Each option's expected value is the probability-weighted sum of its outcomes; the highest wins, and sensitivity analysis checks how firm that is.

Key facts

  • Folding back (averaging out): at each chance node multiply each branch's value by its probability and add; at a decision node keep the best option.
  • Utilities can be elicited from the patient, for example with a standard gamble: the risk of death a person would accept to avoid a state sets its value.
  • QALYs multiply years in a state by its utility; the QALY page shows the arithmetic and how costs are added.
  • Sensitivity analysis: one-way (one input), two-way (two at once) or probabilistic (Monte Carlo draws from each input's range; the share of runs an option wins).
  • NNT against NNH: made-up drug with NNT 25 for a stroke and NNH 50 for a major bleed prevents 2 strokes per bleed caused; whether that is worth it depends on how bad each event is, which utilities supply.
  • When events recur over years, a Markov model (health states, fixed cycles, no memory of the past) replaces a simple tree.

Worked example

  1. Made-up choice: operate now (A) or watch and wait (B). Utilities: well 1.0, well after surgery 0.95, death 0.
  2. A: operative death 2%, so 98% end at 0.95. EV(A) = 0.98 × 0.95 + 0.02 × 0 = 0.931.
  3. B: 70% settle alone (1.0); 30% worsen and need emergency surgery, where 90% recover (0.9) and 10% die (0).
  4. Fold back the emergency branch first: 0.9 × 0.9 + 0.1 × 0 = 0.81.
  5. EV(B) = 0.70 × 1.0 + 0.30 × 0.81 = 0.700 + 0.243 = 0.943.
  6. Base case: B wins by 0.012, a small margin, so the inputs must be tested.
  7. One-way sensitivity on p, the chance of worsening: EV(B) = 1 − 0.19 × p, which equals 0.931 when p ≈ 0.36.
  8. Reading: if this patient's chance of worsening is above about 36%, operating now wins; below it, waiting wins.

Three decision tools that are often confused

FeatureDecision treeMarkov modelThreshold model
QuestionWhich option has the highest expected value for one choiceThe same, when events recur over a long timeAt what probability of disease to test or treat
TimeShort horizon, one-off eventsRepeated cycles of fixed length, often lifelongOne moment of decision
Built fromProbabilities and utilities on branchesHealth states and transition probabilitiesBenefit and harm of treatment, plus test accuracy
OutputExpected value (utility) per optionExpected QALYs, often costs, per strategyA test threshold and a treatment threshold
Main limitBranches multiply when reality is complexNo memory: the next state depends only on the current oneRests on group data and on probabilities and utilities being independent

In practice

  • At the bedside, a small tree built with the patient makes their values explicit in a complex choice and supports shared decisions.
  • Probabilities come from trials or cohorts, adjusted for the patient in front of you; where there are no data, from expert opinion, labelled as such.
  • Guideline panels and health technology assessment use decision models, often with costs added, to compare strategies.
  • Some patients prefer to see the chances of each outcome (a risk analysis) rather than accept the option with the highest expected utility.

Common pitfalls

  • Putting relative risk reductions on the branches: the tree needs absolute probabilities for this patient.
  • Reporting a model without its inputs, ranges and sources, so nobody can check it.
  • Trusting a winning margin without a sensitivity analysis.
  • Modelling options that lie outside the standard of care.

Common traps

  • The option with the highest expected value is best for every patient: it is best on average for the inputs used; a patient with different risks or values may do better with the other option
  • Utilities and probabilities are the same thing: a probability says how likely an outcome is; a utility says how much it is worth, from 0 (death) to 1 (full health)
  • Any winning margin settles the question: when expected values are close, only a sensitivity analysis shows whether the choice holds or flips with plausible inputs
  • A decision model produces new evidence: it only recombines existing data and judgements, so its answer is as good as its inputs
  • If the NNT is smaller than the NNH, treat: counts ignore how bad each outcome is; a rare harm can outweigh a common benefit once outcomes are weighted by utilities

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

The branches leaving a chance node carry probabilities 0.6 and 0.3. What is wrong?

Probabilities leaving one chance node must add up to 1: a 0.1 branch is missing or the numbers are wrong.

Option A has an 80% chance of an outcome worth 0.9 and a 20% chance of one worth 0.5. What is its expected value?

0.8 × 0.9 + 0.2 × 0.5 = 0.72 + 0.10 = 0.82.

Two options differ by 0.005 in expected utility. What should be done before recommending one?

A sensitivity analysis: vary the uncertain probabilities and utilities; if plausible values flip the choice, it is a close call to talk through with the patient.

A drug has NNT 20 for a stroke and NNH 40 for a major bleed. Per 40 patients treated, what happens, and what else is needed to decide?

About 2 strokes prevented and 1 bleed caused; the decision also needs how bad a bleed is compared with a stroke for this patient (the utilities).

Why is a simple decision tree a poor fit for a chronic disease with relapses over decades?

Recurring events over long horizons make the branches multiply; a Markov model with health states and fixed cycles handles them better.

Add to my cards (5)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of epidemiology

Educational content on epidemiological and statistical methods; the examples use made-up numbers to teach the calculation. Not a clinical or legal guide: current Colombian rules are in the official sources.

Sources: Tips for teachers of evidence-based medicine: making sense of decision analysis using a decision tree (Journal of General Internal Medicine, 2009); Medical decision analysis for personalized oncology at the patient bedside (Tumori, 2026); Decision analysis in cardiac surgery: a scoping review and methodological primer (European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, 2024); The threshold model revisited (Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2019).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.