Durgical
EN
Open the app

Health economics and health policy basics: scarcity, payment incentives and how policies are made

  • Concept

Every peso spent on one patient is a peso not spent on another. Health economics shows how systems choose, and how the way providers are paid changes care.

Updated

What it is

Health economics studies how a society uses limited resources for health. Its core ideas are scarcity and opportunity cost (the value of the best alternative given up). Health care is an unusual market: need is unpredictable, patients know less than providers (information asymmetry), insurance makes people use more care (moral hazard) and people who expect to be ill are keener to buy insurance (adverse selection). Systems respond with risk pooling, compulsory enrolment and payment methods that move risk and change incentives. Health policy is the set of decisions and rules that turn these choices into action; it follows a cycle of agenda setting, formulation, adoption, implementation and evaluation.

Key facts

  • Opportunity cost: the real cost of a choice is the health the money would have bought in its best other use.
  • Moral hazard: people use more care when its price at the point of use is low; co-payments try to limit it.
  • Adverse selection: with voluntary enrolment the sickest join first and premiums climb; compulsory enrolment and one benefits plan prevent it, as in the SGSSS.
  • Supplier-induced demand: patients rely on the provider's advice, so a provider paid per service can create demand.
  • Risk pooling: many contributions pay for the few who fall ill; the larger and more mixed the pool, the steadier it is.
  • Evidence, including economic evaluation, feeds every step of the policy cycle.

Worked example

  1. Made-up example: a municipality has 1,000 million pesos for child health and two options.
  2. Option A, a vaccination campaign, costs 400 million and averts an estimated 200 DALYs.
  3. Option B, a new paediatric ICU bed, costs 800 million and averts an estimated 160 DALYs.
  4. Cost per DALY averted: A 400 / 200 = 2 million; B 800 / 160 = 5 million. A gives more health per peso.
  5. Opportunity cost: spending 800 million on B gives up A's 200 DALYs, which needed only half that money.
  6. Paying a clinic: per service at 50,000 pesos a visit, 10 visits a child a year earn 500,000; capitation pays 300,000 a child a year.
  7. Under capitation the clinic keeps 50,000 for every visit it avoids and loses if children need more care: the risk has moved to the clinic.
  8. Reading: compare options per unit of health, count what is given up, and check which way each payment method pushes care. All numbers are made up.

How the way providers are paid moves risk and behaviour

Payment methodPaid forWho carries the financial riskPushes towardsTypical risk
Fee-for-serviceEach service deliveredThe payerMore servicesOveruse, supplier-induced demand
Capitation (like the UPC)Each enrolled person, per periodThe receiver (EPS or provider)Fewer services, preventionUnderuse, avoiding sick enrollees
Case-based (per diagnosis group or package)Each episode or caseThe provider, within the episodeShorter stays, efficiencyEarly discharge, coding cases as more severe
Global budgetA fixed amount per yearThe providerCost controlWaiting lists, rationing
Pay for performanceMeeting quality targetsSharedWhat is measuredNeglect of what is not measured

In practice

  • In Colombia the UPC is a capitation: ADRES pays each EPS a fixed amount per enrollee, so the EPS carries the risk; EPS often pass part of it on to IPS through capitation or package contracts.
  • Compulsory enrolment and one implicit benefits plan are the SGSSS's answer to adverse selection.
  • Economic evaluation (cost per QALY gained or DALY averted) informs which technologies are funded; in Colombia the IETS, created under Law 1438 of 2011 (article 92), assesses health technologies with scientific evidence, and its recommendations are a reference for the benefits plan.
  • Law 1751 of 2015 shows the policy cycle: years of tutela rulings put health as a right on the agenda, Congress formulated and adopted the statutory law, and the Ministry implements it.

Common pitfalls

  • Calling capitation always bad and fee-for-service always good, or the reverse: each method has its own predictable risk.
  • Comparing average costs instead of the cost per unit of health gained.
  • Ignoring opportunity cost: a programme can work and still be the worse use of the money.

Common traps

  • Moral hazard means patients cheat: it means people use more care when it costs them less at the point of use, a normal response to price.
  • Capitation saves money by itself: it moves risk to the receiver, who can save by preventing illness or by denying care; contracts and oversight decide which.
  • Cost-effective means cheap: it means good value per unit of health; an expensive intervention can be cost-effective and a cheap one not.
  • The UPC is the price of a consultation: it is a yearly amount per enrollee that must cover all the UPC-funded care of the plan.

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

An EPS pays a clinic a fixed yearly amount per enrolled child. What behaviour should the EPS watch for, and why?

Underuse and avoidance of sick children: under capitation the clinic carries the risk, so it gains by giving less care. Quality indicators and access audits counter this.

Why is enrolment in Colombia's SGSSS compulsory for everyone?

To prevent adverse selection: if only people expecting to need care enrolled, the pool would be sicker and costlier. Compulsory enrolment keeps healthy and sick people in the same pool.

A programme averts 100 DALYs for 300 million pesos; another averts 50 DALYs for 100 million. Which gives better value?

The second: 2 million pesos per DALY averted, against 3 million for the first.

What is the opportunity cost of funding a new hospital wing?

The health the same money would have produced in its best alternative use, such as a vaccination or primary care programme.

Add to my cards (4)

Connections

← All of epidemiology

Educational content on epidemiological and statistical methods; the examples use made-up numbers to teach the calculation. Not a clinical or legal guide: current Colombian rules are in the official sources.

Sources: Health financing (World Health Organization, 2026); Clinical Resource Management Reimbursement Models and Accountable Care (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2026); Making Choices in Health: WHO Guide To Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (World Health Organization, 2003); Ley 1438 de 2011, por medio de la cual se reforma el Sistema General de Seguridad Social en Salud (Departamento Administrativo de la Función Pública, Colombia (Gestor Normativo), 2011); Ley 100 de 1993 (Departamento Administrativo de la Función Pública, Colombia (Gestor Normativo), 1993).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.