Adjusting therapeutic effort (AET): withholding and withdrawing treatment
- Topic
Every ICU and ward meets it: a treatment that only prolongs dying can be stopped or not started. Done well, it is good medicine, not abandonment.
What it is
Adjusting (or limiting) therapeutic effort, AET, is withdrawing or not starting a treatment such as ventilation, dialysis, vasopressors or artificial nutrition when it is disproportionate for that patient or the patient refuses it. Its aim is to avoid therapeutic obstinacy and let the disease take its course, while symptom relief and palliative care continue. In Colombia, Resolution 813 of 2026 (arts. 3.1 and 14 to 20) regulates it and states that it is not euthanasia.
Key facts
- Proportionality: a measure is disproportionate when its burdens clearly outweigh its benefits for that patient, judged by their values (Res. 813, arts. 3.1 and 14).
- Any measure can be adjusted: resuscitation, ventilation, vasopressors, dialysis, antibiotics, transfusions, artificial nutrition and hydration.
- Time-limited trial: a measure is started with an agreed goal and deadline, and withdrawn if the goal is not met.
- Who starts it (arts. 15 and 16): the doctor or team on clinical judgement, or the patient; if the patient cannot decide, a representative guided by the patient's known wishes or, failing that, best interest.
- The family signs no consent form for AET: they are informed and take part in the discussion, but do not carry the medical decision (art. 16).
- If the team cannot agree, or relatives cannot agree on who represents the patient, the hospital ethics committee is consulted (arts. 15, 16 and 20).
- Law 1733 of 2014, art. 1: people with terminal, chronic, degenerative and irreversible disease may voluntarily and in advance forgo unnecessary medical treatment.
Step by step
- Facts: confirm the diagnosis, the prognosis and what each measure can really achieve; ask a colleague if in doubt.
- Who decides: the capable patient; if not, their DVA, then a representative who knows their wishes.
- Weigh each measure: its burden against its benefit for this patient, by their values, not the team's.
- Meet the patient or family: explain in plain words, propose the plan and give time; they are informed, not asked to sign.
- Write the four lists in the record: withdraw, continue for a set time, continue indefinitely, do not start (art. 17).
- Plan symptom control before anything is withdrawn, and keep supporting the family.
- If disagreement persists, ask the hospital ethics committee: it advises within 15 calendar days (art. 20).
- Review the plan if the clinical picture or the patient's wishes change.
Cases: is it AET, and what do you do?
| Case | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Ventilated after a massive stroke, no chance of meaningful recovery; his wife says he never wanted to live on machines | Agree withdrawal of ventilation with the family, with sedation and pain relief planned for comfort | AET: the measure is disproportionate and matches his known wishes; the disease causes death |
| A capable woman on dialysis says she wants to stop | Check capacity and understanding, offer palliative care, respect the decision | Refusal of life support is part of AET (art. 14); it is not euthanasia |
| Septic patient with an uncertain prognosis; the family wants «everything» | Offer a time-limited trial of intensive care with a clear goal and a review date | It tests the benefit; withdrawing later is ethically equal to not starting |
| A daughter demands CPR for her mother with end-stage cancer; the team sees no benefit | Explain, offer a second opinion and, if disagreement persists, consult the ethics committee | No one must provide a measure with no benefit; the committee advises (arts. 15 and 20) |
| After antibiotics are withdrawn, a nurse asks whether to stop pain relief too | No: continue every comfort measure | AET adjusts treatments, never care: symptom relief is guaranteed (art. 17) |
In clinical practice
- Before ventilation is withdrawn, control of breathlessness and distress is planned so the patient does not suffer.
- If the family asks to «do everything», ask what they fear: often «everything» means «do not abandon him».
- The World Medical Association holds that a capable patient's refusal of treatment must be respected, even if it shortens life.
Legal framework in Colombia
- Resolution 813 of 2026, arts. 3.1 and 14 to 20, checked on 2026-11-15 in the Ministry of Health's Boletín Jurídico No. 04 of 2026: AET aims to prevent therapeutic obstinacy, includes refusal of life support and is not a euthanasia procedure; the ethics committee's opinion is advisory and due within 15 calendar days.
- Law 1733 of 2014, art. 5: the patient has the right to clear information, a second opinion and to take part in decisions; if an adult is unconscious, relatives decide in the order the law sets.
- The Documento de Voluntad Anticipada (Resolution 2665 of 2018) lets a person put in writing their refusal of future measures.
Common traps
- "Stopping a treatment is worse than never starting it": they are ethically equivalent; fearing that a measure can never be stopped leads teams never to try it.
- "Withdrawing a ventilator is euthanasia": it is AET; the disease causes death and the aim is to end obstinacy, not life (Res. 813, art. 3.1).
- "The family must sign a consent before AET": no family signature is required; relatives are informed and take part, but the medical decision is not theirs to carry (art. 16).
- "The ethics committee must approve AET": it is consulted only when there is doubt or conflict, and its opinion is advisory (art. 20).
- "Limiting effort means stopping care": comfort, symptom control and family support continue throughout (art. 17).
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A capable man with motor neurone disease, on long-term ventilation, asks to have it switched off. Is that euthanasia?
No. It is refusal of treatment within AET (Res. 813, arts. 3.1 and 14); the disease causes death. Sedation and symptom control are planned before withdrawal.
A team hesitates to start dialysis because «once started it can never be stopped». How should it frame the start?
As a time-limited trial with an agreed goal and review date. Withdrawing later is ethically equivalent to never starting.
The family agrees with withdrawing support but refuses to sign any document. Can the team go ahead?
Yes. Res. 813 (art. 16) requires no family consent form for AET; the team records the discussion, the reasons and the four lists of art. 17.
Two specialists disagree about stopping vasopressors in a dying patient. What is the next step?
Seek consensus; if it fails, consult the hospital ethics committee, whose opinion is advisory and due within 15 calendar days, while symptom control continues (arts. 15 and 20).
Connections
Educational content on ethics and health law; not legal advice. Laws and case law change: each page links the official text and says when it was last checked. For a real case, read the text in force and ask a lawyer or the medical ethics tribunal.
Sources: WMA Declaration of Venice on End of Life Medical Care (World Medical Association, 2022); WMA Declaration on Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide (World Medical Association, 2019); Ley 1733 de 2014 (Ley Consuelo Devis Saavedra) (Función Pública, Gestor Normativo, 2014); Resolución 813 de 2026 (April), «por medio de la cual se da cumplimiento a las órdenes emitidas por la Corte Constitucional en relación con el derecho a morir dignamente, en sus dimensiones de Eutanasia y de Adecuación de los Esfuerzos Terapéuticos y se dictan otras disposiciones», published in Boletín Jurídico No. 04 of 2026, section 2.2.6, p. 113 (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social, 2026).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
