Durgical
EN
Open the app

Inpatient consultation: answering one well and asking a good question

  • OSCE station

When another team asks for your specialist opinion, the patient only gains if you answer their real question, quickly, clearly and directly to them.

Updated

What it is

An inpatient consultation is the treating team's request for another specialist's opinion or procedure. The consultant clarifies the question and urgency, sees the patient, writes a short note with specific recommendations, tells the requesting doctor directly and follows up.

What is assessed

  • Responding in time, with the urgency the case needs (emergency, urgent or routine).
  • Identifying yourself (name, role, service) and the patient correctly.
  • Clarifying the reason for the request and checking it falls within your field.
  • Gathering first-hand data: the record, results and imaging, plus your own focused history and examination.
  • A concise note: your impression and a limited number of specific recommendations, with reasons and contingency plans.
  • Closing the loop: direct conversation, clear roles, follow-up, and a respectful, teaching tone.

How to do it (and why)

  1. Read the request and ask: what exactly is the question, and how urgent is it? — the answer must fit the question the team actually has.
  2. If the question or urgency is unclear, call the requesting doctor before starting — advice is used more when both agree on the reason.
  3. Review the record, results and imaging, then take a focused history and examine — first-hand data can show what the request missed.
  4. Write the answer to the question first, in one or two lines — the team looks for the answer, not your reasoning process.
  5. Give a few specific recommendations (which test, which drug by generic name, when) with a reason each — vague or exhaustive lists are seldom followed.
  6. Add contingency plans: «if… then…» — the team knows what to do overnight without calling back.
  7. State who does what: which orders you place and which the team keeps — shared tasks with no owner are left undone.
  8. Speak to the requesting doctor: listen first, then give the plan and confirm agreement — a note alone can be missed or misread.
  9. Follow up as often as the case needs and say clearly when you sign off — the consultation ends only when the loop is closed.

The two ends of a consultation

StageThe referring doctor (asking)The consultant (answering)
BeforeDecide the specific question and whether a specialist is neededCheck the question is in your field and how urgent it is
ContactIdentify yourself and the patient; state the urgencyIdentify yourself; listen first, then ask
ContentOne clear question, the relevant history, results and what has been triedFirst-hand data: the record, your examination, the results
OutputAct on the recommendations, or discuss any disagreementA short note: impression, a few specific recommendations, contingencies
ClosingRead back the plan and agree who does whatConfirm agreement, follow up and sign off clearly

Mistakes that cost marks

  • Answering a different question from the one asked, or none at all.
  • Writing recommendations without seeing the patient.
  • A long list with no priorities, reasons or contingency plans.
  • Leaving an urgent recommendation in the chart without speaking to the team.
  • Unclear roles: nobody knows who orders the test or who follows up.
  • Criticising the treating team in the note or in front of the patient (Colombia: Ley 23 de 1981, art. 30).

Self-check list

  • I clarified the question and its urgency.
  • I identified myself and the patient correctly.
  • I reviewed the record and examined the patient myself.
  • I answered the question first.
  • I gave a few specific recommendations, each with a reason.
  • I added contingency plans.
  • I said who does what.
  • I spoke to the requesting doctor directly and confirmed agreement.
  • I planned follow-up or signed off clearly.

Common traps

  • A good consultant deals with everything they find: answer the question asked first, then flag other important findings briefly without taking over the case
  • A note in the chart is communication enough: when it is urgent, speak to the requesting doctor and confirm the plan
  • More recommendations show more expertise: a few specific, reasoned recommendations are more likely to be followed than an exhaustive list
  • The request contains all the information needed: review the record and see the patient, because first-hand data may change the answer
  • Once the note is written the consultation is over: agree who does what, follow up and say when you sign off

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

A surgical team asks cardiology to «evaluate» a 70-year-old woman before hip surgery. What should the consultant do first?

Clarify the specific question (for example, is there active heart disease that should delay surgery?) and how urgent it is, calling the requesting doctor if the request does not say.

Why should the consultant see the patient instead of answering from the request alone?

To gather first-hand data: the request may leave out or misstate key facts, and the consultant's own history, examination and review of results can change the answer.

Which kind of recommendations are most likely to be followed?

A few concise, specific and actionable ones, each with its reason and a contingency plan; long exhaustive lists are implemented less often.

At night a consultant finds a result that needs action within the hour. Is a note in the chart enough?

No. Urgent findings need a direct conversation with the requesting doctor, a read-back of the plan and agreement on who acts, then documentation.

How does Colombian regulation (Decreto 3380 de 1981) describe a junta médica?

As the interconsultation or advice the treating doctor requests from one or more professionals, according to the patient's clinical condition (art. 15).

Add to my cards (5)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All clinical skills

Educational content; it does not replace supervised hands-on training, your institution's protocols or a prescriber's order. A procedure is learnt with a teacher and done only once you are trained to do it.

Sources: Communication between consultants providing advice and referring physicians: a scoping review (BMJ Open) (Europe PMC (open access), 2023); Opportunities to improve the quality of inpatient consultation: one hospital's investigation but an age old struggle (Israel Journal of Health Policy Research) (Europe PMC (open access), 2022); Decreto 3380 de 1981, regulating Law 23 of 1981 (art. 15) (Función Pública, Gestor Normativo, 1981); Ley 23 de 1981, arts. 19 and 30 (Función Pública, Gestor Normativo, 1981).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.