Early tooth loss and space maintainers
- Procedure
When a baby molar is lost early, the teeth beside it can drift into the gap and block the permanent tooth. A space maintainer holds the gap open.
What it is
Primary molars hold space for the premolars. If one is lost early, usually to caries, the first permanent molar can tip forward and close the gap, leading to crowding or impaction of the successor. A space maintainer is a simple appliance, often a band on a molar with a wire loop (band and loop) or a lingual arch, that holds the space until the permanent tooth erupts. Loss of primary incisors rarely needs one.
Indications and contraindications
- Most needed after early loss of a primary second molar, especially before the first permanent molar erupts.
- Check on a radiograph that the successor is present and how soon it will erupt.
- Not needed if the successor is about to erupt or is missing (then the plan is different).
- Types: band and loop, lingual arch, Nance appliance, distal shoe, removable partial appliances.
- Maintainers need regular review: they can break, trap plaque or impede eruption.
How it is done
- Assess the age, the tooth lost, the successor's presence and development, and the bite.
- Choose the appliance for the site and the number of teeth lost.
- Fit bands or take an impression or scan; cement the appliance.
- Teach cleaning around it; review every few months.
- Remove it when the successor erupts.
Which space maintainer for which gap
| Appliance | When it is used | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| Band and loop | One primary molar lost on one side | Simple and cheap; check it does not block the erupting premolar |
| Lower lingual holding arch | Molars lost in the lower arch, once the permanent incisors have erupted | Anchored on both first permanent molars; holds both sides at once |
| Nance appliance | Upper molars lost, often on both sides | Acrylic button on the palate; can irritate the mucosa |
| Distal shoe | Primary second molar lost before the first permanent molar erupts | A blade under the gum guides the unerupted molar into place |
| Removable partial appliance | Several teeth lost, or front teeth for appearance, in a cooperative child | Works only if it is worn |
Complications and pitfalls
- Preventing caries in primary molars is the best space maintenance.
- A broken or loose maintainer must be repaired or removed quickly to avoid tissue damage.
- Space loss can still be regained with orthodontics, but it is harder than keeping it.
Next step / Initial management
- Early loss of a primary molar: refer to the dentist promptly to consider a space maintainer.
- Broken, loose or embedded appliance: refer to the dentist.
- Advise brushing around bands and avoiding sticky sweets.
Common traps
- Every lost primary tooth needs a space maintainer: early loss of primary incisors rarely closes space; molars, especially the second primary molar, are the concern.
- A space maintainer can wait a few months: most space is lost soon after the extraction, so plan it before or right after the tooth comes out.
- A space maintainer is fit and forget: it can break, trap plaque, let the banded tooth decay or block eruption; review it and remove it when the successor erupts.
- If the successor is missing, the space must be kept at all costs: with a congenitally missing premolar the plan may be to keep the primary molar, close the space orthodontically or plan a later implant.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
Why is early loss of a primary second molar a problem?
The first permanent molar can drift forward into the gap, causing crowding or impaction of the second premolar.
When is a space maintainer not needed?
When the successor is about to erupt or is congenitally missing, which calls for a different plan.
What is a band and loop maintainer?
A band cemented on a neighbouring tooth with a wire loop that rests against the tooth on the other side of the gap.
A 5-year-old has a lower primary second molar extracted before the first permanent molar has erupted. Which appliance fits?
A distal shoe, whose blade under the gum guides the unerupted first permanent molar into place and stops it drifting forward.
A 7-year-old loses a primary first molar to caries; the radiograph shows the premolar with little root and covered by bone. What is advised?
A space maintainer, such as a band and loop, because eruption is still years away; review it until the premolar erupts.
Connections
Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a dentist or doctor and is not a clinical instruction. For facial or neck swelling with difficulty swallowing or breathing, a knocked-out tooth or bleeding that will not stop, go to an emergency department at once.
Sources: Survival of Bonded Space Maintainers: A Systematic Review (International Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry (PMC open access), 2018); Anatomy, Head and Neck, Primary Dentition (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Orthodontics, Malocclusion (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
