Durgical
EN
Open the app

The off-duty doctor at a street, event or aircraft emergency

  • First contact

Someone collapses and a voice asks for a doctor. Without a team or a monitor, your best tools are a safe scene, a call to 123, your hands and a clean handover.

Updated

What it is

An off-duty doctor who meets an emergency on the street, at an event or on a flight acts as a first responder with medical knowledge but without the hospital's equipment, team or records. In Colombia the medical ethics law (Ley 23 de 1981) lets a doctor decline or stop care only outside emergencies (art. 7), says the doctor gives the benefits of medicine to anyone who needs them (art. 3), and forbids making emergency care depend on prior payment (art. 23). The criminal code (Ley 599 de 2000, art. 131) punishes anyone who, without just cause, fails to help a person whose life or health is in grave danger. The job is to make the scene safe, call the emergency system, do the few things that save life with what is at hand, stay within your competence, and hand over to the ambulance crew or the receiving team with a clear account.

What to look for

  • Is the scene safe for you and the patient (traffic, crowd, fire, violence)?
  • Is the person responsive, and are they breathing normally? If not, it is a cardiac arrest until proven otherwise.
  • Is there catastrophic bleeding, choking or an airway at risk?
  • Who else is helping: another health worker, trained staff, event medics, the cabin crew?
  • What is at hand: an AED, a first-aid or aircraft medical kit, gloves, a phone?
  • Can the patient consent, and is there a relative or companion who knows the history?

Step by step (and why)

  1. Check the scene and protect yourself — a second casualty helps nobody.
  2. Say clearly that you are a doctor and what your field is — the crew or organiser needs to know who is helping.
  3. Call 123, or have someone call, and send for an AED — the system and the shock take time to arrive.
  4. Do the life-saving basics: CPR and AED, bleeding control, the choking manoeuvres, recovery position — they need no hospital.
  5. Ask for consent if the patient can give it; take a brief history and look for medic-alert cards or medicines — they guide the crew.
  6. Do not move the patient unless the place is dangerous, and do not give drugs you cannot justify — harm from a well-meant act is still harm.
  7. When the crew arrives, hand over and offer to help under their lead — they bring the equipment and the protocols.
  8. Write down what you saw and did, with times, and give a copy to the crew — memory fades and the record protects the patient.

What to do and what not to do as a bystander doctor

DoDo notWhy
Identify yourself and your fieldPretend to skills you lackThe team must know what you can safely do
Call 123 and send for an AEDWait to be sure before callingHelp and defibrillation take minutes to arrive
Control bleeding, keep the airway open, start CPRStart procedures that need equipment you do not haveThe basics save the most lives outside hospital
Leave the patient where they are unless the place is unsafeMove them to a car or carry them without needMoving can worsen injuries and delays the ambulance
Stay until a crew or team takes overLeave once the patient seems betterPatients can deteriorate, and someone must hand over
Hand over a short account with timesArgue over who leadsA clean handover transfers responsibility safely

Findings that change the plan

  • A man collapses at a football match and is not breathing normally: start compressions, send for the stadium AED and call the event medical team and 123.
  • At a street crash, a doctor's most useful acts are often making the scene safe, stopping bleeding and keeping people from moving the injured.
  • An unconscious diabetic at a party: put them in the recovery position and call for help; giving anything by mouth to an unconscious person risks aspiration.
  • On a flight, the captain decides about diversion; the doctor advises through the cabin crew and the ground medical service.

Next step

  • Give the crew a structured handover: what happened, what you found, what you did and at what time.
  • Write a note with times and actions as soon as possible and keep a copy.
  • If a death or a suspected crime occurs, stay available to the authorities as a witness.
  • Keep basic life support skills current with a certified course.

Common traps

  • An off-duty doctor may decline to help: in an emergency the ethics law does not allow a Colombian doctor to excuse themselves
  • Helping exposes the doctor to more legal risk than walking away: failing without just cause to help someone in grave danger is a crime
  • A doctor should take charge from the ambulance crew: the crew brings the equipment and the protocols; offer help under their lead
  • Loading the patient into a private car is faster than waiting: moving them can worsen injuries and skips the care given on the road
  • Once the crew arrives the doctor's job is over: the handover with times, findings and treatments is part of the care

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

An off-duty doctor sees a cyclist hit by a car. Why does Colombian ethics law not allow her to walk away?

Because Ley 23 de 1981 allows a doctor to decline care only outside emergencies (art. 7), and the criminal code punishes failing to help a person in grave danger without just cause (art. 131).

Passers-by want to put an injured motorcyclist in a taxi to the hospital. What should the doctor advise, and why?

Leave him where he is unless the place is dangerous, call 123 and control bleeding; moving him can worsen a spinal or other injury, and the ambulance brings care and direction to the right hospital.

The ambulance arrives with a medicalised crew. What is the doctor's role now?

To give a clear handover with times and actions and to offer help under the crew's lead; the crew now has the equipment, the protocols and the link to the receiving hospital.

Why should the bystander doctor write down what happened afterwards?

Because memory fades and the receiving team needs the times and treatments; a written account also documents that the care given was reasonable.

Add to my cards (4)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of emergency medicine

Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or a medical assessment. It contains no doses. In a real emergency, call the emergency number (123 in Colombia) or go to the nearest emergency department; for poisoning, contact the toxicology line (CIATOX in Colombia).

Sources: Ley 23 de 1981, por la cual se dictan normas en materia de ética médica (Función Pública, Gestor Normativo, 1981); Ley 599 de 2000, Código Penal, art. 131 (omisión de socorro) (Superintendencia Nacional de Salud (normograma), 2000); Resolución 926 de 2017, Sistema de Emergencias Médicas (primer respondiente, línea 123) (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social (normograma Supersalud), 2017); Chandra A, Conry S. In-flight medical emergencies. West J Emerg Med 14(5):499–504 (Western Journal of Emergency Medicine (PubMed Central, open access), 2013).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.