Durgical
EN
Open the app

Health system models: Beveridge, Bismarck, national health insurance and out-of-pocket

  • Concept

Who pays when someone falls ill decides who gets care and who goes broke. Four classic models answer that, and Colombia mixes them.

Updated

What it is

A health system model describes where the money for care comes from and who provides it. The classic four are Beveridge (taxes fund a national health service), Bismarck (compulsory payroll contributions to sickness funds), national health insurance (one public insurer pays independent providers) and out-of-pocket (patients pay when ill). Real systems mix them.

Key facts

  • Universal health coverage has three dimensions: who is covered, which services are covered, and how much protection there is from the cost.
  • Pooling in advance (taxes or contributions) spreads the cost of the few who fall ill across the many; out-of-pocket payment pools nothing.
  • Bismarck systems can have a single fund or several competing insurers (as in Germany).
  • The Bismarck model dates from the late 19th century in Germany; the Beveridge model from the British National Health Service of 1948.
  • Out-of-pocket financing dominates in many low- and middle-income countries and also hits uninsured or under-insured people in rich ones.
  • In Colombia ADRES pools the money and pays each EPS a capitation (UPC) per enrollee; the EPS contract IPS that deliver the care.
  • Classify a real system by its dominant source of money and its main providers: almost every system mixes features.

Worked example

  1. Made-up case: an appendectomy with 3 days in hospital costs 10 million pesos; the patient earns 2 million pesos a month.
  2. Out-of-pocket: she pays 10 million at discharge, 5 months of income; she may delay surgery or fall into debt.
  3. Beveridge: the cost was paid in advance through general taxes; the state hospital charges her little or nothing.
  4. Bismarck: her sickness fund, fed by her and her employer's payroll contributions, pays the hospital; she may owe a small co-payment.
  5. National health insurance: the single public insurer pays the private hospital at a negotiated price.
  6. Colombia: her EPS in the contributory scheme pays the IPS from its UPC; if she could not pay contributions, the subsidised scheme would cover her.
  7. Reading: the 10 million is the same in every model; what changes is when it is paid (before or at illness) and by whom (everyone, workers or the sick).

The four classic models and where Colombia sits

ModelMoney comes fromWho provides careTypical weak pointExamples
Beveridge (national health service)General taxesMostly public services run by the StateWaiting lists when the budget is tightUnited Kingdom
Bismarck (social health insurance)Compulsory payroll contributions to sickness fundsMostly private providersPeople outside formal work fall through unless the State covers themGermany, France, Japan
National health insurance (single payer)One public insurer, funded by taxes or premiumsPrivate providersEverything depends on one payer's budget and pricesCanada, Taiwan, South Korea
Out-of-pocketThe patient, at the moment of illnessWhoever the patient can payCatastrophic spending; the poor go without careCommon where pooling is weak
Colombia's SGSSS (structured pluralism)Payroll contributions plus public funds, pooled by ADRESPublic and private IPS contracted by competing EPSFragmentation of funds and actorsColombia (Law 100 of 1993)

In practice

  • When a patient delays care «until payday», financing is the barrier: ask about costs like any other risk factor.
  • In Colombia, check the scheme (contributory or subsidised) and the EPS first: they decide which network will see the patient.
  • Exam vignettes: «tax-funded, the State runs the hospitals» = Beveridge; «payroll contributions to sickness funds» = Bismarck; «one public insurer, private doctors» = national health insurance.

Common pitfalls

  • Calling every public system «Beveridge»: in national health insurance the State pays but does not own the providers.
  • Assuming universal coverage means care is free at the point of use.
  • Comparing countries by model name alone instead of by how much people pay out of pocket.

Common traps

  • Colombia has a Beveridge system because the State guarantees health: it is compulsory insurance through competing EPS, funded by payroll contributions and public money, closer to Bismarck with a subsidised scheme
  • Single payer means the State runs the hospitals: in national health insurance one public insurer pays independent providers; in Beveridge the State also provides the care
  • Out-of-pocket financing exists only in poor countries: it also affects uninsured and under-insured people in rich countries
  • Universal coverage means everything is free: it combines coverage of people, of services and of costs, and co-payments can remain

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

A country funds care through general taxes and most hospitals and doctors work for a national service. Which model is it?

Beveridge: tax funding plus State provision, as in the British National Health Service.

In country X workers and employers pay compulsory contributions to sickness funds, which pay private clinics. Which model is it, and which group is at risk of being left out?

Bismarck (social health insurance). People outside formal employment are at risk unless the State covers them, which is the role of Colombia's subsidised scheme.

How does national health insurance differ from the Beveridge model?

Both pool money publicly, but in national health insurance one public insurer pays independent, mostly private providers; in Beveridge the State also runs the services.

Why is Colombia's SGSSS described as «structured pluralism» rather than a national health service?

Because several competing EPS insure people and contract public and private IPS, under State rules and a pooled fund (ADRES), instead of the State providing all the care.

A family sells its land to pay for a hospital stay. Which financing model produced this, and what is the remedy?

Out-of-pocket payment. The remedy is pooling in advance, through taxes or compulsory contributions, so that the cost of illness is shared.

Add to my cards (5)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of epidemiology

Educational content on epidemiological and statistical methods; the examples use made-up numbers to teach the calculation. Not a clinical or legal guide: current Colombian rules are in the official sources.

Sources: Universal health coverage evolution, ongoing trend, and future challenge: a conceptual and historical policy review (Ranabhat CL et al., Front Public Health) (Europe PMC, 2023); Universal health coverage (UHC) (World Health Organization, 2025); Political and institutional determinants of the Colombian health system financing fragmentation (Losada-Trujillo N et al., BMC Health Serv Res) (Europe PMC, 2026); Ley 100 de 1993 (Departamento Administrativo de la Función Pública, Colombia (Gestor Normativo), 1993).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.