Durgical
EN
Open the app

The red scaly plaque: psoriasis, eczema, tinea and their look-alikes

  • Approach

Red patches with flaky skin are among the commonest reasons to see a doctor. Five questions about the edge, scale and place usually name the disease.

Updated

See it in 3D: Skin

What it is

Papulosquamous diseases produce sharply defined red papules and plaques covered by scale. The main ones are psoriasis, tinea (dermatophyte infection), pityriasis rosea, lichen planus, secondary syphilis, discoid and subacute lupus, and squamous cell carcinoma in situ; chronic eczema enters the differential because it scales too, but its edge is blurred. The edge (sharp or blurred), the scale (thick silvery, greasy, peripheral, collarette), the distribution and the time course separate them, and a KOH preparation settles the commonest confusion: psoriasis or eczema versus tinea.

Red flags

  • Red flags: a single plaque in an older adult that grows and bleeds (carcinoma in situ, basal cell carcinoma); erythroderma (the whole skin red); fever, joint pain or pustules on a plaque.
  • Psoriasis: sharp borders, thick silvery scale, extensors, scalp, umbilicus and natal cleft; nail pitting; bleeding points when scale is removed.
  • Tinea corporis: annular, active scaly edge, clearing centre, asymmetric, often itchy; contacts with pets or other people with ringworm.
  • Pityriasis rosea: herald patch then oval patches with an inner collarette of scale along skin lines of the trunk; clears in about two months.
  • Secondary syphilis: copper-red scaly papules including palms and soles, with lymph nodes, mouth lesions or patchy hair loss.

Step-by-step approach

  1. Is the edge sharp (psoriasis, tinea, lupus, carcinoma) or blurred (eczema)?
  2. What is the scale like: thick silvery (psoriasis), greasy yellow (seborrhoeic), at the leading edge (tinea), collarette inside the edge (pityriasis rosea)?
  3. Where is it: extensors and scalp, flexures, trunk along skin lines, sun-exposed face, palms and soles?
  4. One lesion or many; symmetric or not; how long?
  5. Scrape the edge for KOH before applying any steroid.
  6. Look at nails, scalp, mouth, genitals and joints.
  7. Test for syphilis if palms and soles are involved or the patient has risk factors; biopsy a single plaque that does not behave.

Telling scaly plaques apart

DiseaseEdgeScaleWhereClinch it
PsoriasisSharpThick, silveryElbows, knees, scalp, natal cleftNail pits; family history
Chronic eczemaBlurredFine, with lichenificationFlexures, handsAtopy, intense itch
Tinea corporisSharp, active ringAt the advancing edgeAnywhere, asymmetricKOH shows hyphae
Pityriasis roseaOvalCollarette inside the edgeTrunk along skin linesHerald patch first
Secondary syphilisDefinedFineTrunk, palms and solesPositive serology
Discoid lupusSharpAdherent, with follicular plugsFace, ears, scalpScarring, pigment change
Carcinoma in situ (Bowen)Sharp, irregularCrustySun-exposed, older adultSingle, slowly growing: biopsy

Keys to the differential

  • Psoriasis is a systemic inflammatory disease: ask about joint pain and screen for obesity, diabetes, dyslipidaemia, fatty liver and depression.
  • Guttate psoriasis (many small drops on the trunk) often follows a streptococcal sore throat by about two weeks.
  • Systemic corticosteroids can make psoriasis flare badly, even into pustular psoriasis, when they are stopped.
  • Beta-blockers, lithium, antimalarials and stopping corticosteroids can trigger or worsen psoriasis.

Next step

  • KOH preparation of any annular or asymmetric scaly plaque; fungal culture if KOH is negative but suspicion stays.
  • Syphilis serology (a non-treponemal and a treponemal test) when palms and soles are involved or there are risk factors.
  • Biopsy a single persistent plaque in an older adult, or any plaque that ulcerates or bleeds.
  • Refer to dermatology for psoriasis with joint symptoms, extensive disease, pustules or erythroderma (emergency), or when the diagnosis stays unclear.

Common traps

  • A red scaly ring is eczema, so a steroid is fine: if it is tinea, the steroid lets it spread and lose its ring («tinea incognito»).
  • An antifungal-steroid mixture covers every option «just in case»: in eczema or psoriasis it only delays the right diagnosis.
  • A non-itchy rash like pityriasis rosea cannot be syphilis: secondary syphilis looks exactly like that; check palms, soles, mouth and serology.
  • Psoriasis is only skin deep: up to about a third develop psoriatic arthritis, sometimes before the skin.
  • Systemic corticosteroids are a good option for psoriasis: the rebound when they stop can be severe.

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

An itchy annular plaque was treated with a steroid cream and is now larger and has lost its clear edge. What happened?

It was tinea: the steroid suppressed inflammation and let the fungus spread (tinea incognito). KOH or culture will show it.

A young adult has a scaly rash on the trunk that looks like pityriasis rosea but also involves the palms. What test is needed?

Syphilis serology: secondary syphilis mimics pityriasis rosea but involves palms and soles.

Which questions should a doctor ask every patient with psoriasis beyond the skin?

Joint pain and stiffness (psoriatic arthritis) and risk factors for cardiovascular and metabolic disease, which are more common in psoriasis.

Add to my cards (3)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of dermatology

Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a doctor or dermatologist and is not a clinical instruction. For a rash with fever, painful skin, blisters or peeling, sores in the mouth or eyes, or a swelling throat, go to an emergency department at once.

Sources: Psoriasis (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Tinea Corporis (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Pityriasis Rosea (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Syphilis (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Psoriasis (National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases (NIAMS), 2024).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.