Mass-casualty triage systems compared: START, SALT, JumpSTART and the sieve–sort family
- Concept
When fifty people are hurt at once, a triage system decides in seconds who is treated first; knowing how the systems differ shows what each one can miss.
What it is
Mass-casualty triage sorts many patients quickly into priority groups by simple observations rather than diagnoses. START (adults) and its paediatric version JumpSTART use walking, breathing, perfusion and obeying commands. SALT (sort, assess, life-saving interventions, treatment/transport) was developed in 2008 as an all-hazards, all-ages US standard: a global sort by movement, a short list of life-saving interventions before assessment, four yes/no questions, and an explicit expectant category for patients unlikely to survive with the resources available. The sieve–sort family (MIMMS and its successors in the UK) separates a fast primary sieve at the scene from a more detailed secondary sort later. Triage is repeated at every level, and no system is accurate enough to be used once.
Key points
- Primary triage (sieve) is fast, needs no equipment and can be done by anyone; secondary triage (sort) adds blood pressure, consciousness score and senior judgement in a calmer place.
- SALT's life-saving interventions are few: control major bleeding, open the airway (two rescue breaths in a child), decompress the chest, give an autoinjector antidote.
- A systematic review found no clearly best system: over-triage ranged up to about half of patients and under-triage up to more than half, depending on the tool.
- Under-triage kills salvageable patients; over-triage floods theatres and intensive care and delays the truly critical. Systems aim to keep under-triage very low and accept some over-triage.
- Older adults are under-triaged by every tool tested: normal vital signs can hide serious injury.
- Colombia's five-level emergency triage (Resolución 5596 de 2015) runs daily emergency flow; in a mass-casualty event colour triage takes over and its waiting times do not apply.
Step by step
- Global sort by voice: ask those who can walk to go to a set place, then those who can wave to wave; the still and the obviously threatened are seen first.
- Life-saving interventions, only if quick and within skill: stop major bleeding, open the airway, decompress the chest, autoinjector antidote.
- Not breathing after the airway is opened (and two rescue breaths in a child): tag black, dead, and move on.
- Ask four questions: obeys commands or moves purposefully? peripheral pulse? no respiratory distress? major bleeding controlled?
- All four yes and only minor injuries: green, minimal. All four yes but more than minor injuries: yellow, delayed.
- Any answer no: is survival likely with the resources available now? Yes → red, immediate. No → grey, expectant.
- Treat and transport red first, then yellow, then green; give expectant patients comfort care and re-triage them as resources arrive.
- Repeat triage at every handover — patients deteriorate, improve and are first mis-sorted under pressure.
How the main mass-casualty triage systems differ
| Feature | START | JumpSTART | SALT | Sieve–sort family |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built for | Adults | Children | All ages, all hazards | Adults; newest versions all ages |
| First move | Walkers to one side | Walkers to one side; carried infants assessed | Global sort: still first, then those who wave, walkers last | Walkers to one side; catastrophic bleeding first in newer versions |
| Where bleeding control sits | After the breathing and perfusion checks | After the breathing and pulse checks | Before assessment, with the other life-saving interventions | First step in the newer sieves |
| Expectant category | None of its own; black covers the dead | None of its own | Grey: unlikely to survive with current resources | Not part of the primary sieve |
| Second look | Re-triage, no formal tool | Re-triage, no formal tool | Treatment and transport order, then re-triage | Formal secondary sort with blood pressure and consciousness score |
In practice
- Expectant is a resource decision, not a prognosis written in stone: the same patient would be red on an ordinary day and becomes red again when help arrives.
- Expectant patients are not abandoned: they get pain relief, comfort, a name on the list and regular reassessment; the decision is taken by the most experienced clinician available and recorded.
- Age, disability or social worth are never triage criteria; only the likelihood of benefit with the resources available counts.
- Use the system your region trains on at every level; mixing systems in one event confuses tags and handovers.
Next step
- Find out which mass-casualty triage system your region and hospital use, and practise it.
- At the hospital door, re-triage every arrival even if it carries a tag.
- Record category, time and changes on the tag and the tracking list.
- After drills and real events, audit under- and over-triage and feed it back.
Common traps
- The black tag means the patient was left to die: in SALT black is only for the dead, and the living unsalvageable are grey, kept comfortable and reassessed
- Expectant is a fixed label for the worst injured: it depends on today's resources, so the same patient becomes immediate when help arrives
- Over-triage is the safe mistake: too many reds swamp theatres and intensive care and delay the salvageable critical patients
- Bleeding is controlled after the breathing count: SALT and the newer sieves stop catastrophic bleeding first because it kills within minutes
- One triage at the scene settles the priority: every tool misclassifies some patients, so triage is repeated at each handover
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
In SALT, a casualty breathes, obeys commands, has a radial pulse and no distress, but has an open femur fracture with bleeding controlled. Which category?
Yellow, delayed: all four questions are answered yes, but the injury is more than minor, so the patient can wait for treatment without immediate risk.
Why does SALT ask 'is survival likely with current resources?' only after an abnormal answer?
Because it separates two very sick groups: those who can be saved with what is available now (red) and those who cannot (grey), so scarce resources go where they change outcomes.
A grey-tagged patient is still alive when a second ambulance team and blood arrive. What happens?
Re-triage: expectant depends on resources, so with more help the patient may become red and receive full treatment.
Why do newer triage sieves put catastrophic bleeding before the breathing count?
Massive external bleeding kills within minutes and is fixed in seconds with pressure or a tourniquet; counting breaths first wastes the time in which the patient bleeds out.
What is the difference between a triage sieve and a triage sort?
The sieve is the fast primary triage at the scene, by simple observations and without equipment. The sort is a later, more detailed secondary triage that adds blood pressure, consciousness score and senior judgement.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Mass-casualty triage (START and JumpSTART) from the nursing side
- Allocating scarce resources and triage
Connections
Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or a medical assessment. It contains no doses. In a real emergency, call the emergency number (123 in Colombia) or go to the nearest emergency department; for poisoning, contact the toxicology line (CIATOX in Colombia).
Sources: SALT Triage (Sort, Assess, Lifesaving Interventions, Treatment/Transport) (Chemical Hazards Emergency Medical Management (CHEMM), US Department of Health and Human Services, 2025); Kman NE et al. SALT triage training and virtual reality demonstration. JACEP Open (PubMed Central, 2024); Bazyar J et al. Accuracy of triage systems in disasters and mass casualty incidents: a systematic review. Arch Acad Emerg Med (PubMed Central, 2022); Vassallo J et al. New NHS prehospital major incident triage tool: from MIMMS to MITT. Emerg Med J (PubMed Central, 2022); The BCD Triage Sieve outperforms all existing major incident triage tools. eClinicalMedicine (PubMed Central, 2021); Triage (Resolución 5596 de 2015): cinco categorías; los tiempos no aplican en emergencias o desastres con múltiples víctimas (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social de Colombia, 2025).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
