Durgical
EN
Open the app

The family meeting and the goals-of-care conversation

  • Technique

The big decisions of serious illness are made in one planned conversation. Done well, it prevents unwanted treatment and years of family regret.

Updated

What it is

A goals-of-care conversation finds out what the patient understands about the illness, what matters most to them, what they fear and which trade-offs they would accept, and then turns that into a medical plan. When the family is involved, or when the patient can no longer decide, it takes the form of a family meeting: a planned, private meeting of the patient (if able), the people they choose and the relevant members of the team. Good meetings follow a structure. The team prepares first and agrees on the medical facts and on the recommendation, so that the family does not hear different stories. The meeting opens with introductions and its purpose, finds out what the family already knows, gives information in plain words at the pace they want, makes room for emotion, explores the patient's values and, if the patient cannot speak, asks what they would have chosen. It ends with a recommendation that follows from those values, a summary, a plan and a named contact. The decision is shared: the doctor brings the medical options and their likely results, the patient or family bring the values, and the doctor is expected to recommend rather than hand over a menu. Everything is documented and the plan is shared with the team. In Colombia the patient's right to information, to take part in decisions and to sign an advance directive, and the family's role when the adult is unconscious, are set by Ley 1733 de 2014.

Indications

  • A new serious diagnosis or a clear change in trajectory (repeated admissions, falling function).
  • A decision about life-sustaining treatment: ICU admission, ventilation, dialysis, resuscitation, artificial nutrition.
  • The patient can no longer decide and the family has to speak for them.
  • Disagreement within the family or between the family and the team.
  • Discharge planning for care at home or in a hospice, or the patient's wish about place of death.
  • Routinely, early, for any patient entering palliative care, not only in a crisis.

Contraindications and precautions

  • Do not use the meeting to argue the medical facts among the team; resolve that beforehand.
  • Check the patient's capacity and wishes about who attends and what may be shared.
  • Use a trained interpreter when language differs; never a child of the patient.
  • Severe family conflict may need a psychologist or mediator and more than one meeting.
  • Respect cultural and religious ways of deciding, while keeping the capable patient's right to decide.

Equipment and preparation

  • A team pre-meeting: diagnosis, prognosis as a range, realistic options and the team's recommendation.
  • A convenor who leads, and only the staff the family needs (about two or three).
  • A quiet private room, enough chairs, tissues, phones silenced, enough time (usually under an hour).
  • Knowledge of any advance directive and of what the patient has said before.

Step by step (and why)

  1. Introduce everyone, state the purpose and ask permission: «Can we talk about how things are going and plan ahead?».
  2. Ask what they understand and how much they want to know; correct gaps from where they are.
  3. Give the key message in one or two plain sentences, a warning shot first if the news is bad.
  4. Stop and respond to emotion (name it, acknowledge it); information does not land on a frightened mind.
  5. Explore what matters most, fears, sources of strength and abilities the patient would not trade.
  6. If the patient cannot decide, ask: «If he could hear us, what would he tell us?».
  7. Recommend a plan that fits those values, including what will be done, not only what will stop.
  8. Summarise, check understanding, agree the next step and name a contact person.
  9. Document the meeting and share the plan with the whole team.

Shared decision vs menu vs paternalism

ApproachWho brings whatWhat the family hearsResult
Menu of optionsDoctor lists interventions; family chooses«It is up to you whether he lives»Guilt, conflict, treatment the patient would not want
PaternalismDoctor decides alone«This is what we will do»Values ignored, trust lost
Shared decision with a recommendationDoctor brings options and outcomes; patient or family bring values; doctor recommends«Because what matters to her is X, we recommend Y»A plan that fits the person, with the weight shared

Complications

  • Asking «do you want everything done?» pushes the family into choosing between love and death; ask about goals instead.
  • A family left with a menu feels it alone «decided to let him die»; a recommendation shares that weight.
  • Information given before emotion is acknowledged is not heard and is later reported as «nobody told us».
  • Team members giving different messages destroys trust; that is why the pre-meeting comes first.
  • Undocumented decisions are reopened at 3 a.m. by a covering doctor who never heard them.

Next step

  • Write a note: who attended, what was understood, the patient's values, decisions, what continues and the contact person.
  • Update orders to match the plan (resuscitation status, ICU admission, tests, place of care).
  • File any advance directive or the patient's recorded wishes in the record.
  • Share the plan with the team, the covering doctors and the primary care team.
  • Call the main carer within a few days and offer a follow-up meeting if things change.

Common traps

  • A good meeting gives the family every option and lets them choose: the doctor recommends a plan that follows from the patient's values
  • Asking whether they want everything done: it frames limits as abandonment; ask what matters most and recommend accordingly
  • The family decides what the patient gets: they report what the patient would have wanted, and a capable patient decides for himself
  • Explaining more facts calms a crying relative: respond to the emotion first, then give information
  • Stopping life-sustaining treatment means stopping care: say clearly what will continue (comfort, presence, symptom control)

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

Before a family meeting about a ventilated patient with no realistic recovery, the intensivist and the surgeon disagree. What do you do first?

Hold a team pre-meeting to agree on the facts, the prognosis range and the recommendation; the family meeting is not the place to argue medicine.

Why is «do you want everything done?» a poor question?

It turns limits into a choice between love and death and puts the weight on the family; asking what matters most and then recommending a plan shares that weight.

The patient cannot speak and her children disagree. Which question refocuses the meeting?

Ask what she would say if she could hear them, what she valued and said before; the decision follows her values, not each child's wishes.

A daughter starts crying when you say her father is dying. What is the next step?

Pause and respond to the emotion (name it, acknowledge it, allow silence) before giving more information.

What does a good family-meeting note record?

Who attended, what they understood, the patient's values, the decisions, what will continue and what will stop, the next steps and the named contact person.

Add to my cards (5)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of anaesthesia

Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or the anaesthetist's or intensivist's decision. It contains no doses and no ventilator or infusion settings.

Sources: Family meetings in palliative care: multidisciplinary clinical practice guidelines (BMC Palliative Care (PubMed Central), 2008); Development of the Serious Illness Care Program: a randomised controlled trial of a palliative care communication intervention (BMJ Open (PubMed Central), 2015); Last Days of Life (PDQ), Health Professional Version (National Cancer Institute, 2025); Ley 1733 de 2014 (Ley Consuelo Devis Saavedra) (Función Pública, Gestor Normativo, 2014).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.