Durgical
EN
Open the app

Palliative care beyond cancer: heart failure, COPD, kidney failure, dementia and ALS

  • Concept

Most people who need palliative care do not have cancer. Their decline is less predictable, so they are referred late or never.

Updated

What it is

Heart failure, chronic lung disease, kidney failure, liver failure, dementia, frailty and neurological diseases such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) cause most of the world's palliative need, yet these patients reach palliative care later than people with cancer. The reason is the shape of the illness. Murray and colleagues described three typical trajectories. In cancer, function is fairly well kept until a short, recognisable decline over the last weeks to months. In organ failure (heart failure, COPD), function falls slowly with acute exacerbations, each followed by partial recovery, and death can come suddenly in any one of them, often when the patient was expected to live longer. In frailty and dementia, function starts low and dwindles over years, and a minor event such as a fall, a fracture or pneumonia can end life. Because organ failure and dementia never give a clean «terminal» signal, palliative care has to be added by need, alongside the disease treatment that still relieves symptoms, and planning has to be done early, while the patient can still take part. Each disease has its own key decisions: device deactivation and continued diuretics in heart failure; non-invasive ventilation and hospital admission in COPD; dialysis or conservative kidney management in kidney failure; feeding tubes and transfers in advanced dementia; ventilation and gastrostomy in ALS. Implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICDs) deserve a planned talk: their shocks can hit a dying patient repeatedly, and turning the shock function off is ethically and legally the withdrawal of a treatment the patient no longer wants.

Key points

  • WHO: among adults who need palliative care, cardiovascular disease is the largest group, followed by cancer and chronic respiratory disease.
  • In heart failure, breathlessness and fatigue are very common and depression may affect up to half of patients.
  • Many patients with ICDs receive shocks as they die if the device is not reprogrammed; a do-not-resuscitate order does not switch off an ICD.
  • Turning off the shock function usually leaves pacing working; pacing is reviewed separately, especially in pacemaker-dependent patients.
  • In COPD, markers of advanced disease include breathlessness at rest, long-term oxygen, repeated admissions and need for ventilation.
  • In ALS, decisions about non-invasive ventilation, gastrostomy and tracheostomy are best made early, before speech and breathing fail.
  • Patients in organ failure often underestimate how serious their illness is, so families can be shocked by an expected death.

How it works

  • Organ failure: each exacerbation removes reserve that does not fully return, so the baseline steps down.
  • Dementia and frailty: reserve is already minimal, so a small insult (infection, fall) tips the balance.
  • ALS: progressive weakness of bulbar and respiratory muscles drives the decisions (swallowing, speech, breathing).
  • Kidney failure: dialysis prolongs life in many patients, but in the frail and multimorbid it may add little time and much burden.

Step by step

  1. Identify the trajectory and the markers of advanced disease for this illness.
  2. Ask the surprise question at each exacerbation or admission.
  3. Keep or optimise disease treatment that relieves symptoms; stop what only adds burden.
  4. Hold a goals-of-care conversation before the next crisis, while the patient can take part.
  5. Plan the disease-specific decisions: device settings, ventilation, dialysis, feeding, hospital transfer.
  6. Write the plan where the emergency and out-of-hours teams will see it, and review it after each step down.

Palliative care by disease

IllnessTrajectorySigns of advanced diseaseKey palliative decisions
Heart failureOrgan failure: stepwise decline, sudden death possibleBreathlessness at rest, repeated admissions despite optimal therapy, worsening kidney functionICD shock deactivation, keeping diuretics, resuscitation status, assist devices
COPDOrgan failure: exacerbations with partial recoveryBreathlessness at rest, long-term oxygen, repeated admissions, previous ventilationAdmission and ventilation limits, breathlessness control, rehabilitation
Kidney failureOrgan failure; slower in conservative careFrailty, multimorbidity, falling function on or before dialysisDialysis vs conservative kidney management, stopping dialysis
DementiaProlonged dwindlingUnable to walk, speak meaningfully or eat without help, recurrent infectionsHand feeding vs tube, antibiotics, hospital transfer
ALSSteady neurological decline, respiratory failureWeak swallow and breathing, weight lossNon-invasive ventilation, gastrostomy, tracheostomy, communication aids

In practice

  • Heart failure: continue diuretics and other symptom-relieving drugs to the end; plan ICD shock deactivation and resuscitation status; for ventricular assist devices, plan with the cardiology team.
  • COPD: offer pulmonary rehabilitation and symptom control for breathlessness; agree in advance whether the next exacerbation should mean admission, non-invasive ventilation or intubation.
  • Kidney failure: present dialysis and conservative kidney management as two real options; if dialysis is stopped, death usually follows within days to weeks and symptom control continues.
  • Advanced dementia: treat pain and discomfort, use careful hand feeding, avoid burdensome transfers, and decide in advance about antibiotics and hospital admission.
  • ALS: involve the multidisciplinary team early and record decisions about ventilation and gastrostomy while the patient can communicate.
  • ICD deactivation: discuss at implant, when goals change and when death approaches; in an emergency a clinical magnet over most ICDs suspends shocks while it stays in place.

Next step

  • Name the trajectory and the markers of advanced disease in the notes.
  • Review the medicines: keep those that relieve symptoms and stop those that only prevent distant events.
  • Schedule a goals-of-care conversation before the next exacerbation.
  • For an ICD, discuss shock deactivation and arrange reprogramming with the device team if agreed.
  • Share a written plan with the emergency, primary care and home teams.

Common traps

  • Palliative care waits until heart failure treatment has failed: diuretics and other symptom-relieving drugs continue alongside palliative care
  • A do-not-resuscitate order also turns off the ICD: the device keeps shocking unless it is reprogrammed
  • Turning off an ICD is euthanasia: it withdraws an unwanted treatment and the underlying disease causes the death
  • A feeding tube prevents aspiration in advanced dementia: it does not prevent aspiration or prolong life, and careful hand feeding is preferred
  • Every patient with kidney failure should start dialysis: conservative kidney management is a legitimate planned choice for some frail patients

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

A man with advanced heart failure and an ICD is now dying at home. What should be discussed about the device?

Turning off the shock function, which is painless and does not stop the heart, so he is not shocked while dying; a do-not-resuscitate order alone does not turn it off.

Why are patients with organ failure referred to palliative care later than patients with cancer?

Their trajectory is a stepwise decline with recoveries after each exacerbation and possible sudden death, so there is no clear terminal signal; care has to be added by need.

The family of a woman with advanced dementia who aspirates asks for a feeding tube. What is the evidence?

In advanced dementia tube feeding does not prevent aspiration or prolong life and adds burdens; careful hand feeding for comfort is preferred.

An 85-year-old with kidney failure, heart failure and frailty is offered dialysis. What alternative should be presented?

Conservative kidney management: no dialysis, with active treatment of symptoms, fluid balance and anaemia, and planning for the end of life.

Add to my cards (4)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of anaesthesia

Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or the anaesthetist's or intensivist's decision. It contains no doses and no ventilator or infusion settings.

Sources: Illness trajectories and palliative care (BMJ (PubMed Central), 2005); Palliative care (fact sheet) (World Health Organization, 2020); Palliative care in heart failure: facts and numbers (ESC Heart Failure (PubMed Central), 2017); Features and outcomes of patients who underwent cardiac device deactivation (JAMA Internal Medicine (PubMed Central), 2014); Screening tools for the early identification of palliative care needs in patients with advanced chronic conditions: an updated systematic review (Journal of Clinical Medicine (PubMed Central), 2026).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.