Durgical
EN
Open the app

Shared decision-making in the consultation: options, numbers and teach-back

  • Topic

When two options are both reasonable, the right one depends on the patient. You bring the numbers, they bring what matters, and you decide together.

Updated

What it is

Shared decision-making is how to run a consultation when the decision is preference-sensitive: two or more reasonable options (including waiting) whose benefits and harms people value differently. The clinician gives the options and their odds in plain numbers, the patient says what matters, and they decide together, checking understanding.

Step by step

  1. Ask first: is this preference-sensitive? Two or more reasonable options, including waiting, whose trade-offs people value differently.
  2. Team talk: say there is a choice, that you will help them through it, and ask about goals: 'What matters most to you in the coming years?'
  3. Ask how involved they want to be, and whom they want with them: family, a carer or an interpreter.
  4. Option talk: list every reasonable option, including doing nothing or watchful waiting, and what each involves day to day.
  5. Give benefits and harms as natural frequencies, same denominator and time span: 'Of 100 people like you, over 10 years…'
  6. Show both framings (how many helped, how many not) and use a good-quality decision aid or icon array if one exists.
  7. Chunk and check: after each chunk, teach-back: 'So I know I explained it well, how would you tell your family?'
  8. Decision talk: ask what matters most now that they have the numbers; give your view if asked; allow time and set a review date.
  9. Record the options discussed, what the patient valued, the decision and the review date; consent for the chosen option follows.

Four look-alikes: who weighs the trade-offs?

FeatureClinician recommendsShared decision'Here are the options, you choose'Informed consent
When it fitsOne option clearly wins, or an emergencyOptions are balanced; the best one depends on valuesNever on its own: it leaves the patient aloneBefore any intervention, whichever model was used
Patient's goals asked?Not essentialYes, first and again at the endNoNot required in itself
Numbers givenMain benefit and risksAbsolute benefits and harms of every option, in both framingsOften a list of facts without guidanceNature, risks, benefits and alternatives
Clinician's viewGiven as the planOffered, and fitted to what the patient valuesWithheldGiven, then the patient decides freely
What comes outA recommendation the patient accepts or refusesA decision both understand, with a review dateA choice the patient may not understandThe patient's authorization (or refusal)

Clinical notes

  • Typical preference-sensitive decisions: cancer screening (prostate, colorectal, breast), early cancer treatment choices, joint replacement, and many cardiovascular and mental-health treatments.
  • Not every decision is shared: when evidence clearly favours one option, recommend it plainly; the patient still keeps the right to accept or refuse.
  • Some patients want the information but not the whole responsibility; shared decision-making allows this, provided they know a choice exists and their goals are known.
  • Decision aids (Cochrane, 209 trials): more knowledge, more accurate risk perception, less decisional conflict and choices closer to the patient's values; no difference in regret.
  • Decision aids used before the visit did not lengthen it; used during the visit they added about one and a half minutes.
  • Risk formats (Cochrane, 35 studies): natural frequencies are understood better than probabilities; relative reductions look larger and persuade more; the NNT is the format understood least well.
  • Pictures help when paired with numbers: NICE advises icon arrays alongside the rates; in one randomised study icon arrays and bar graphs were understood equally well.
  • Words such as 'rare' or 'common' mean different things to different people; give the number when there is one.
  • Low health literacy, a language barrier, pain or fear: shorter chunks, an interpreter, a companion if the patient wants one, and more teach-back.
  • The legal requirements for consent in Colombia (qualified consent, minors, capacity) are on the ethics pages; shared decision-making is how the conversation before it is done well.

Common traps

  • Listing the options and letting the patient pick: leaving someone alone with the numbers is abandonment, not sharing; support, goals and your view when asked are part of the job.
  • Quoting the relative reduction ('halves the risk'): it sounds large and persuades more but hides the baseline; say 'from 2 in 1 000 to 1 in 1 000 over 5 years'.
  • Asking 'Do you understand?': almost everyone says yes; ask them to explain it back in their own words, and treat a wrong answer as your explanation failing.
  • Sharing every decision: when one option clearly wins, or in an emergency, you recommend; sharing is for decisions where reasonable options are in balance.
  • Treating the signed form as proof of a shared decision: the form records consent to one intervention; it does not show that options, numbers or values were discussed.

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

A 55-year-old man asks about prostate cancer screening. The benefits and harms are close and people weigh them differently. Do you recommend or share, and why?

Share: it is preference-sensitive, with two reasonable options whose trade-offs depend on his values. Use team, option and decision talk, ideally with a decision aid, and include not screening as an option.

A drug 'halves the risk of stroke', from 2 in 1 000 to 1 in 1 000 over 5 years. How do you put this to the patient, and what is the NNT?

'Of 1 000 people like you, 2 without the drug and 1 with it have a stroke in 5 years; the other 998 have none either way.' Absolute reduction 1 in 1 000, so the NNT is 1 000 for 5 years.

After explaining hip replacement versus continuing physiotherapy, you ask 'Is that clear?' and she nods. What should you do instead?

Teach-back: 'So I know I explained it well, how would you tell your daughter the two options and the main risk of each?' Correct what is missing, then check again.

A patient says, 'You are the doctor, just choose for me.' Can the decision still be shared, and how?

Yes: respect the wish to delegate, but first make sure he knows there is a choice and ask what matters to him; then recommend the option that fits those values and record that he chose to delegate.

An alert man with suspected bacterial meningitis needs antibiotics now. Why is this not a shared decision-making conversation, and what still applies?

One option clearly wins and delay harms, so you recommend it plainly. He still has the right to be told what and why and to accept or refuse: that is consent, not a choice between balanced options.

Add to my cards (5)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of the clinical exam

Educational content on the clinical exam; it is learned and practised under supervision. It does not replace assessment by a health professional and is not for self-diagnosis.

Sources: A three-talk model for shared decision making: multistage consultation process (Elwyn and colleagues, BMJ 2017;359:j4891) (Europe PMC, 2017); Shared decision making (NICE guideline NG197): Recommendations (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (UK), 2021); Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions (Stacey and colleagues, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2024) (Europe PMC, 2024); Using alternative statistical formats for presenting risks and risk reductions (Akl and colleagues, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2011, CD006776) (Europe PMC, 2011); Comparing the impact of an icon array versus a bar graph on preference and understanding of risk information (Scalia and colleagues, PLoS One 2021) (Europe PMC, 2021); Utilizing the 'teach-back' method to improve surgical informed consent and shared decision-making: a review (Seely and colleagues, Patient Safety in Surgery 2022) (Europe PMC, 2022).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.