Migration and health: the healthy migrant effect, displacement and barriers to care
- Concept
Migrants often arrive healthier than the people they join, then lose that edge. Knowing what the journey does to health guides what to ask and offer.
What it is
Migration and health studies how moving across or within borders affects health before, during and after the journey. In 2024 about 304 million people were international migrants, and 117.3 million were forcibly displaced: 73.5 million internally displaced people, 36.4 million refugees and 8.4 million asylum seekers (WHO). Health depends less on being a migrant than on the conditions of the move: chosen labour migration and forced displacement carry very different risks.
Key facts
- Healthy migrant effect: migrants often have better health than the population they left and, especially in the first 5–10 years, than the host population. Explanations: healthier people migrate, sicker people return ('salmon bias'), protective habits.
- The advantage erodes: within 5–10 years migrants' health can match or fall below the host population's, as poverty, insecure work, stress and new habits act.
- The effect is clearer in labour migrants than in refugees and family-reunion migrants, in whom it is weak or absent.
- Refugees have crossed a border fleeing persecution or conflict and have international protection; internally displaced people flee within their own country and remain under its protection.
- Needs along the route: injuries and violence (including gender-based violence), maternal and newborn care, communicable disease and missed vaccines, anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress, and interrupted treatment of chronic disease.
- Barriers: legal status and documents, cost, language and culture, xenophobia and discrimination, fear of deportation and lack of information.
- Colombia is a major host country: by September 2023 almost 2.9 million of the 7.3 million people who had left Venezuela since 2015 lived there; temporary protection announced in 2021 opened a route to regular status and health insurance.
Worked example
- Survey of 917 Venezuelan women who gave birth in Colombia: 564 had 4 or more prenatal visits.
- Proportion = 564 / 917 = 61.5%: about 4 in 10 had fewer than 4 visits.
- With regular migration status 68.1% reached 4 or more visits; with irregular status, 59.0%.
- Crude ratio = 59.0 / 68.1 ≈ 0.87; adjusted prevalence ratio 0.88 (95% CI 0.78–0.99): about 12% lower.
- Women denied care for being Venezuelan: adjusted prevalence ratio 0.57, a 43% lower chance of completing 4 visits.
- Reading: regular status and care without discrimination at the front desk have measurable effects on maternal care.
Labour migrant, refugee and internally displaced person
| Feature | Labour migrant | Refugee | Internally displaced person |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crosses a border? | Yes | Yes | No |
| Why they move | Work, family or study, mostly chosen | Persecution, conflict or violence, forced | Conflict, violence or disaster, forced |
| Protection | The host country's migration law | International refugee protection | Their own State |
| Healthy migrant effect | Often present on arrival | Weak or absent | Usually absent |
| Main health risks | Work injuries, chronic disease later, poor access | Trauma, mental health, communicable disease, interrupted treatment | Similar to refugees, often in camps or informal urban settlements |
In practice
- Ask three things: where from, which route and for how long, and current legal status and insurance; each changes what to look for and what the person can access.
- Catch up vaccines and screen by origin and route (for example tuberculosis, HIV, syphilis, hepatitis B, malaria or Chagas disease where relevant), with consent and never as a condition of care.
- Restart interrupted chronic treatment early: people with HIV, diabetes, hypertension or epilepsy often arrive without medicines or records.
- Ask gently about violence and mental health, and use trained interpreters rather than children for sensitive conversations.
- In Colombia, emergency care is owed to everyone whatever their status; the rights and court rulings are on the ethics page on migrants' care.
Common pitfalls
- Treating migrants as one group: labour migrants, refugees and internally displaced people have different risks.
- Reading low migrant mortality in registers as good health: unregistered departures and returns (salmon bias) can hide deaths.
- Blaming culture for poor outcomes that come from legal status, cost and discrimination.
Common traps
- Migrants bring disease to the host country: most arrive healthier than the host population, and their health worsens after arrival through poverty, insecure work and poor access
- The healthy migrant effect lasts a lifetime: it fades within about 5–10 years and is weak or absent in refugees
- Refugees and internally displaced people are the same: refugees have crossed a border and have international protection; internally displaced people stay in their own country under its protection
- Few prenatal visits in migrant women reflect personal choice: irregular status and discrimination at the point of care independently lower prenatal attendance
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A Venezuelan man who arrived 8 years ago now has obesity and hypertension, which he did not have on arrival. Which concept explains this?
Erosion of the healthy migrant effect: the advantage on arrival fades within about 5–10 years as poverty, stress, work conditions and new habits act.
A woman displaced by violence from rural Chocó to Bogotá: is she a refugee?
No. She has not crossed an international border, so she is an internally displaced person, protected by her own State; her health needs (trauma, interrupted care) are similar.
A pregnant migrant with irregular status at 28 weeks has had no prenatal visits. What does the evidence point to, and what can the clinic change?
Irregular status and discrimination independently lower prenatal attendance; the clinic can receive her without status checks at the door, give the care owed and guide her towards regularisation.
Why can registers show unusually low death rates in migrants?
Partly salmon bias: people who leave or go home ill stay on the register, so their deaths are not recorded and migrants look healthier than they are.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Health care for migrants in Colombia
- Global health and justice
- Prenatal care: what each visit is for
- Colombia's PAI schedule (which vaccines, at what age)
Connections
Educational content on epidemiological and statistical methods; the examples use made-up numbers to teach the calculation. Not a clinical or legal guide: current Colombian rules are in the official sources.
Sources: Refugee and migrant health (fact sheet) (World Health Organization, 2026); Healthy migrant effect in the Swedish context: a register-based, longitudinal cohort study (BMJ Open (PubMed Central), 2019); Factors associated with attendance to and completion of prenatal care visits in Colombia among urban-residing Venezuelan refugee and migrant women (Journal of Migration and Health (PubMed Central), 2024).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
