The person-centred, biopsychosocial consultation
- Approach
The same diagnosis lands differently in every life. Asking what the person thinks, fears and wants turns a correct diagnosis into a plan they will follow.
What it is
The biopsychosocial model, proposed by George Engel in 1977, holds that biological, psychological and social factors act together in every illness. The person-centred clinical method turns it into a way of running the consultation: explore both the disease (what the doctor finds) and the illness (what the person lives through), understand the whole person in their family and context, find common ground on the problem and the plan, and build the relationship over time. In Colombia the life-course consultations of Res. 3280 de 2018 ask the doctor to explore the family's expectations and concerns and to apply the family APGAR at each visit.
Step by step in the consultation
- Open with an open question and let the person finish; ask «anything else?» until the list of concerns is complete.
- Agree the agenda: decide together what fits today and what moves to the next visit.
- Explore the disease: focused history, examination and red flags, as in any clinical method.
- Explore the illness: ideas about the cause, concerns, expectations for today and the effect on daily life and work.
- Widen the lens: family, work, money, mood, alcohol and support; under Res. 3280 the family APGAR belongs in each life-course visit.
- Summarise both stories back in plain words and check that you understood.
- Find common ground: explain in the person's terms, offer options, agree the plan and who does what.
- Check understanding with teach-back, give specific return advice and set the follow-up.
Disease and illness: two sides of one problem
| Feature | Disease | Illness |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Abnormal structure or function the doctor can name and measure | The person's experience of being unwell |
| Who knows it best | The doctor | The person and their family |
| How it is explored | Symptom history, examination, tests | Ideas, concerns, expectations, effect on daily life |
| One without the other | Silent hypertension: disease without illness | Persistent symptoms with normal tests: illness without detected disease |
| Cost of ignoring it | Missed or late diagnosis | Plans not followed, repeat visits, dissatisfaction |
In practice
- A 52-year-old man with type 2 diabetes keeps «forgetting» his tablets. Asked about his ideas, he says his brother went blind «from the medicine»: the fear, not the memory, is the problem to address.
- A woman brings her child for a cough but the real concern is a neighbour's child who died of pneumonia: naming that fear changes what reassurance must cover.
- Persistent physical symptoms with normal tests: the biopsychosocial frame avoids both missing disease and ordering tests without end.
Common pitfalls
- Interrupting the opening statement: concerns that were not voiced at the start often never get said.
- Recording only the biomedical problem list: the psychosocial findings vanish for the next doctor.
- Using a psychosocial explanation to stop examining: a person under stress can still have a serious disease.
Common traps
- Biopsychosocial means the problem is psychological: it means all three levels act together; a heart attack has social causes and a depression has biological ones
- Making the diagnosis ends the consultation: a correct diagnosis with a plan the person does not accept changes nothing, which is why finding common ground is part of the method
- Person-centred means doing whatever the patient asks: it means deciding together; the doctor still brings the evidence and may disagree, for example about antibiotics for a cold
- Asking about ideas and concerns is extra work for when there is time: a few targeted questions fit inside the history and catch the hidden fear that would otherwise sink the plan
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A patient with normal tests keeps returning with abdominal pain. Is this disease or illness, and what comes next?
Illness without detected disease. Recheck red flags, then explore ideas, concerns, expectations and context, and agree a plan with scheduled follow-up instead of more tests by default.
Why can a clearly explained plan still fail when ideas, concerns and expectations were not explored?
The plan may clash with an unspoken belief or fear, such as the idea that the medicine causes harm, so the person does not follow it.
What are the four components of the person-centred clinical method?
Exploring disease and the illness experience, understanding the whole person, finding common ground, and enhancing the doctor–patient relationship.
Under Res. 3280, what does the doctor apply in an adult when bereavement or family dysfunction appears in the history?
The Whooley questions for depression and the GAD-2 for anxiety; a positive result leads to the pathway for mental health problems.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Screening questionnaires in primary care
- Communication skills: open questions, empathy and teach-back
- Models of the doctor–patient relationship and patient-centred care
- The psychology of pain: gate control and the biopsychosocial model
- The medical interview: rapport, open questions and listening
- Motivational interviewing
Connections
Educational content on the family-medicine and primary-care approach. Not a clinical or legal guide: current Colombian care pathways and rules are in the official sources.
Sources: The biopsychosocial model 25 years later: principles, practice, and scientific inquiry (Borrell-Carrió, Suchman, Epstein), Annals of Family Medicine 2(6) (Europe PMC (PMC1466742), 2004); Patient- or person-centred practice in medicine? A review of concepts (Louw, Marcus, Hugo), African Journal of Primary Health Care and Family Medicine (Europe PMC (PMC5675925), 2017); Pendleton's Ideas, Concerns and Expectations model for improving outcomes through eye donation counseling (Milner et al.), Indian Journal of Ophthalmology (Europe PMC (PMC8012926), 2021); The European Definition of General Practice / Family Medicine, 2023 edition (WONCA Europe, 2023); Resolución 3280 de 2018: lineamientos de la Ruta Integral de Atención para la Promoción y Mantenimiento de la Salud y de la Ruta Materno Perinatal (Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social de Colombia, 2018).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
