Choosing a contraceptive method: effectiveness and eligibility
- Method or treatment
The best method is the one a woman can use safely and will keep using. Two questions find it: how well it works in real life, and whether her health allows it.
See it in 3D: Body of uterus · Cervix · Uterine tubes
What it is
Contraceptive methods range from long-acting reversible contraception (the implant and intrauterine devices), through injectables, pills, patches and rings, to barrier methods, fertility awareness and sterilisation. Their real-life effectiveness depends mostly on how much they rely on the user. Medical safety is checked with the WHO Medical Eligibility Criteria (MEC), which grade each method for each condition from 1 (no restriction) to 4 (unacceptable risk). The choice is the woman's, after counselling on effectiveness, side effects, STI protection and how to stop.
How it works and how well
- Implant, hormonal IUD, copper IUD and sterilisation: fewer than 1 pregnancy per 100 women in the first year of typical use.
- Injectable: about 4 per 100; pill, patch and ring: about 7 per 100, because doses are missed.
- Male condom about 13, withdrawal about 20 and female condom about 21 per 100 with typical use; condoms are the only methods that also protect against STIs.
- The copper IUD is also the most effective emergency contraceptive, and works for years afterwards.
- Fertility returns quickly after stopping all methods except the injectable, which can delay it for some months.
Main methods compared
| Method | How it works | User effort | Main cautions (WHO MEC 3–4) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Copper IUD | Copper is toxic to sperm and eggs | None for up to 10 years or more | Current pelvic infection, unexplained bleeding, distorted cavity, pregnancy |
| Levonorgestrel IUD | Thickens cervical mucus, thins the endometrium | None for years | Current pelvic infection, current breast cancer, unexplained bleeding |
| Implant | Progestogen blocks ovulation | None for 3 to 5 years | Current breast cancer; irregular bleeding is the main side effect |
| Injectable progestogen | Blocks ovulation | An injection every few months | Bone density loss with long use; slow return of fertility |
| Combined pill, patch, ring | Oestrogen + progestogen block ovulation | Daily, weekly or monthly | Migraine with aura, smoker over 35, past thrombosis, uncontrolled hypertension, first weeks after birth |
| Progestogen-only pill | Thickens mucus; some block ovulation | Daily, on time | Current breast cancer |
| Condoms | Barrier | Every act | None; latex allergy |
Risks and who should not use it
- Combined (oestrogen) methods are not used by women with migraine with aura, smokers aged 35 or over, a history of venous thrombosis or a known clotting mutation, uncontrolled hypertension, current breast cancer, or in the first weeks after birth.
- Enzyme-inducing drugs (for example rifampicin, some antiepileptics and antiretrovirals) reduce the effect of pills, patches, rings and implants; IUDs and injectables are unaffected.
- Neither adolescence nor never having been pregnant is a reason to refuse an IUD or implant.
- Irregular bleeding is the commonest reason women stop progestogen-only methods; warn about it beforehand.
Next step / Follow-up
- Before starting: exclude pregnancy with reasonable certainty, check blood pressure for oestrogen methods, and review the WHO MEC; a pelvic examination or cervical cytology is not needed to start the pill, implant or injectable.
- Timing after birth or abortion follows the WHO MEC 6th edition (2025), which changed the postpartum and breastfeeding categories: see the postpartum contraception page.
- Offer long-acting methods first, without pressure, together with condoms for STI protection when needed.
- Follow up for side effects and satisfaction; make removal available on request.
- Refer for IUD or implant insertion, or for sterilisation, when not available on site, and for women with complex conditions (MEC category 3 or 4 for several methods).
Common traps
- Comparing methods by 'perfect use' figures: typical use is what happens in real life, and pills fail far more often than implants.
- Insisting on a pelvic examination or cytology before starting the pill: it is a barrier, not a requirement.
- Assuming common antibiotics (like amoxicillin) stop the pill: only enzyme inducers such as rifampicin do.
- Refusing an IUD to a young woman who has never been pregnant: it is safe and highly effective.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A 37-year-old who smokes 20 cigarettes a day asks for the combined pill. What do you advise?
Combined oestrogen methods carry an unacceptable cardiovascular risk for her; offer a progestogen-only method or an IUD.
Why does the implant fail far less often than the pill in real life, although both work well with perfect use?
The implant needs no action once inserted, whereas the pill depends on daily use and missed pills cause most failures.
A woman on rifampicin uses an implant. Is her contraception reliable?
No; rifampicin induces liver enzymes and lowers progestogen levels. An IUD or an injectable is unaffected, and condoms can be added meanwhile.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Contraception counselling: the methods, eligibility in general terms, LARC and after birth or abortion
- Contraception: how each method prevents fertilization or implantation
- Contraception and sexual rights of adolescents
Connections
See it in 3D3
The structures of Durgical's 3D anatomy where it is found.
In Pharmacology1
← All of obstetrics and gynaecology
Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a doctor or your institution's protocols, and it contains no doses. For heavy bleeding, a severe headache or blurred vision, a seizure, fever, strong abdominal pain or fewer baby movements, go to an emergency department at once.
Sources: Medical eligibility criteria for contraceptive use, 6th ed. (World Health Organization, 2025); About contraception: methods and effectiveness (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2024); Contraception (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Postcoital Contraception (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Family planning/contraception methods (fact sheet) (World Health Organization, 2025).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
