The child with a murmur: innocent or not?
- Approach to a problem
Most children have a heart murmur at some point, and most are innocent. A few features separate the harmless ones from those that need an echocardiogram.
See it in 3D: Interventricular septum · Interatrial septum
What it is
A heart murmur is the sound of turbulent blood flow. Innocent (functional) murmurs come from normal flow in a normal heart and are heard in up to most children at some age, often louder with fever, anaemia or exercise. Pathological murmurs come from structural heart disease (septal defects, valve stenosis or regurgitation). The history, the child's growth and symptoms, and the murmur's characteristics guide who needs further tests.
Red flags
- Innocent murmur features: systolic, soft (grade 1–2), short, musical or vibratory, changes with position, normal S2, no thrill, well child.
- Common innocent murmurs: Still's murmur (vibratory, lower left sternal border), venous hum (continuous, disappears lying down or with neck pressure), pulmonary flow murmur.
- Red flags: diastolic murmur, loud (grade 3 or more) or harsh murmur, thrill, abnormal S2, clicks, poor growth, sweating with feeds, cyanosis, syncope, chest pain on exertion.
- A fixed split S2 suggests atrial septal defect; a holosystolic murmur suggests VSD or mitral regurgitation.
- Check femoral pulses: weak femorals with a murmur suggest coarctation.
Step-by-step approach
- Ask about feeding, sweating, growth, breathlessness, syncope and family history of heart disease or sudden death.
- Examine growth, colour, pulses including femorals, and look for syndromic features.
- Listen: timing, loudness, site, radiation, quality, S2, change with position.
- Classify: innocent features only, or red flags.
- Red flags or doubt: ECG, chest X-ray if needed, and echocardiography with paediatric cardiology.
Innocent versus pathological
| Feature | Innocent | Pathological |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Systolic | Any diastolic, or holosystolic |
| Loudness | Soft, grade 1–2 | Grade 3 or more, thrill |
| Change with position | Often changes or disappears | Fixed |
| Second heart sound | Normal | Abnormal (fixed split, single, loud) |
| The child | Well, growing | Symptoms, poor growth, syndrome |
Keys to the differential
- Murmurs often appear with fever or anaemia; re-examine when the child is well.
- Children with Down syndrome and other syndromes need an echocardiogram regardless of the murmur.
Next step / Initial management
- Innocent features in a well child: reassure; no tests needed.
- Any red flag: ECG and echocardiography.
- Pathological murmur, symptoms or a syndrome: refer to paediatric cardiology.
Common traps
- Any murmur means heart disease: most murmurs in children are innocent.
- A loud murmur means a big defect: a small VSD is loud; a large one can be quiet.
- A murmur heard during a fever needs immediate echocardiography: re-examine when the child is well first, unless red flags.
- A soft diastolic murmur can be innocent: diastolic murmurs are always pathological.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A healthy 5-year-old has a soft vibratory systolic murmur at the lower left sternal border that softens when he sits up. Next step?
This is a typical Still's innocent murmur; reassure, no tests needed.
A 3-year-old has a continuous murmur below the clavicle that disappears when lying down. What is it?
A venous hum, an innocent murmur.
Which murmur feature is always pathological?
A diastolic murmur.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
Connections
See it in 3D2
The structures of Durgical's 3D anatomy where it is found.
Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a doctor and is not a clinical instruction. If a child has difficulty breathing, cannot drink, vomits everything, has a seizure, is very drowsy, or is a baby under three months with fever, go to an emergency department at once.
Sources: Heart murmurs (MedlinePlus, U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2024); Ventricular Septal Defect (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Congenital heart disease (MedlinePlus, U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2024).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
