Brain death: the clinical exam and the law in Colombia
- Concept
Brain death is death, diagnosed by a careful exam of the brainstem. In Colombia the law says how and by whom, and it is separate from the donation decision.
See it in 3D: Midbrain · Pons · Medulla oblongata · Oculomotor nerve (III) · Vagus nerve
What it is
Brain death (muerte encefálica) is the irreversible loss of all brain function, including the brainstem, in a patient whose heart is kept beating by intensive care. It is legally and medically death. The diagnosis requires a known, catastrophic and irreversible cause; exclusion of anything that can mimic it (sedative drugs, neuromuscular blockers, hypothermia, severe metabolic or endocrine disturbance, shock); coma with no motor response of brain origin; absence of all brainstem reflexes; and apnoea despite a strong respiratory stimulus. Ancillary tests of cerebral blood flow or electrical activity are used when the clinical examination cannot be completed. In Colombia, Decreto 2493 de 2004 defines brain death and sets who diagnoses it, and Ley 1805 de 2016 governs organ donation.
Key points
- The cause must be visible and sufficient: large haemorrhage, massive infarct, severe trauma or prolonged hypoxia with imaging to match.
- Spinal reflexes can persist after brain death: limb withdrawal, plantar flexion and slow trunk movements do not refute the diagnosis.
- The apnoea test checks that no breath appears when carbon dioxide is allowed to rise while oxygenation is maintained; it is done only after the other criteria are met and stopped if the patient becomes unstable.
- Drug effects must be cleared: wait for elimination, measure levels or use an ancillary test if the drug cannot be excluded.
- The Colombian decree lists the signs to document, including no spontaneous breathing, fixed pupils without light reflex, and absent corneal, oculovestibular, gag and cough reflexes.
- It also states that the diagnosis does not apply when toxic or reversible metabolic changes, depressant drugs, muscle relaxants or hypothermia are present.
- Children, especially newborns and infants, follow specific criteria with longer or repeated observation.
Brain death versus its look-alikes
| Condition | Brainstem reflexes | Breathing | Reversible? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brain death | All absent | Absent on apnoea test | No: it is death |
| Deep sedation or drug overdose | May all be absent | May be absent | Yes, once the drug clears |
| Severe hypothermia | May be absent | Depressed | Yes, with rewarming |
| Locked-in syndrome | Vertical eye movements and blinking present | Present | Patient fully aware |
| Vegetative state | Present | Present | Alive, with variable prognosis |
In practice
- Explain to the family that the patient has died, in plain words, before any mention of donation; the donation conversation is a separate step, usually led by the trained donation team.
- Document every element: cause, exclusions, each reflex, the apnoea test or ancillary test, the physicians and the time.
- Severe Guillain-Barré syndrome and high cervical cord injury can abolish many reflexes and breathing; the history and imaging prevent a false diagnosis.
- Physiological support may continue after death for donation; the diagnosis does not depend on the donation decision.
Next step
- Confirm the cause on imaging and exclude confounders: temperature, blood pressure, sodium, glucose, drug levels, neuromuscular blockade check.
- Complete the brainstem examination and the apnoea test following the institution's protocol under the Colombian decree.
- Ancillary test of cerebral blood flow or EEG when the clinical exam or apnoea test cannot be done or confounders remain.
- Two or more independent physicians outside the transplant programme, one a specialist in the neurological sciences; record time and findings in the chart.
- Inform the family clearly; notify the donation network per protocol and keep the donation conversation separate.
Common traps
- Movements of the legs disprove brain death: spinal reflexes can persist after the brain has died.
- The patient dies when the ventilator is switched off: legally and medically, death occurs when brain death is diagnosed.
- An EEG is always required: the diagnosis is clinical, and ancillary tests are for when the clinical exam or apnoea test cannot be completed.
- The transplant team can make the diagnosis to save time: Colombian law requires physicians who are independent of the transplant programme.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A patient after a large intracerebral haemorrhage has no brainstem reflexes, but he received a long infusion of a sedative and is cold. Can brain death be declared now? Why?
No: sedation and hypothermia are confounders that can abolish brainstem function reversibly; correct temperature, let the drug clear or use an ancillary blood flow test first.
After brain death is diagnosed, a nurse sees the patient's leg withdraw when the foot is touched. Does this change the diagnosis?
No: withdrawal can be a spinal reflex that persists after brain death; only responses mediated by the brain refute the diagnosis.
Why does Colombian law require that the physicians who diagnose brain death not belong to the transplant team?
To prevent any conflict of interest: the diagnosis of death must be independent of the interest in obtaining organs, which protects patients and public trust.
When is an ancillary test such as a cerebral blood flow study needed in brain death?
When part of the clinical exam cannot be done (facial trauma, unstable apnoea test) or a confounder such as a drug cannot be excluded.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Brain death: clinical testing (Colombia)
- Brain death: the ethical and legal criteria in Colombia
- Ley 1805 de 2016: presumed consent for organ donation
- Pupils: light reflex and abnormal pupils (Marcus Gunn, Horner, Argyll Robertson)
- Arousal and consciousness: the reticular activating system
Connections
See it in 3D5
The structures of Durgical's 3D anatomy where it is found.
Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or a medical assessment. It contains no doses. For signs of stroke (face drooping, arm weakness, speech trouble), a prolonged seizure or fever with a stiff neck, call the emergency number (123 in Colombia) or go to the nearest emergency department.
Sources: Brain Death (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Decreto 2493 de 2004 - Gestor Normativo - Función Pública (Departamento Administrativo de la Función Pública (Colombia), 2004); Ley 1805 de 2016, que modifica la Ley 73 de 1988 y la Ley 919 de 2004 en materia de donación de componentes anatómicos (Superintendencia Nacional de Salud, Normograma, 2016).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
