Durgical
EN
Open the app

Vacuum and forceps: when and when not

  • Method or treatment

When the head is low but labour stalls or the baby is in trouble, a vacuum cup or forceps can end the birth faster than a caesarean, if conditions are right.

Updated

See it in 3D: Pubic symphysis · Perineal body · External anal sphincter

What it is

Operative (assisted) vaginal birth uses a vacuum extractor or forceps to help deliver the baby's head in the second stage of labour. It is used for a prolonged second stage, suspected fetal compromise, or when the mother should not or cannot push (some heart or neurological conditions, exhaustion). It is safe only when strict conditions are met: cervix fully dilated, membranes ruptured, head engaged and low enough, exact position known, adequate analgesia, empty bladder, consent and an operator able to stop and move to caesarean. Forceps succeed more often but cause more maternal perineal tears; vacuum fails more often and causes more scalp and head bleeding in the baby.

How it works and how well

  • Prerequisites: fully dilated cervix, ruptured membranes, head no more than one-fifth palpable above the pubis, station at or below the ischial spines, position known, analgesia, empty bladder, consent, backup for caesarean.
  • Vacuum: a cup on the flexion point of the head; descent with each pull is expected; easier to apply, less maternal trauma, more failures.
  • Forceps: blades that cradle and guide the head; higher success, more third- and fourth-degree tears.
  • Stop if there is no descent with each pull or the birth is not imminent after a few pulls; move to caesarean.
  • Using a second instrument after the first fails raises the risk of injury to the baby.

Vacuum versus forceps

FeatureVacuumForceps
SuccessLower; the cup can detachHigher
Maternal injuryFewer severe perineal tearsMore third- and fourth-degree tears
Baby injuryScalp swelling (chignon), cephalhaematoma, subgaleal haemorrhage, retinal bleeds, jaundiceFacial marks, facial nerve palsy, rarely skull fracture
Gestational ageAvoided before about 34 weeksCan be used in preterm babies
Not used forFace presentation, fetal bleeding disorderUnknown position, head too high

Risks and who should not use it

  • Contraindications for both: cervix not fully dilated, head not engaged or too high, unknown position, suspected disproportion, non-cephalic presentation (except forceps for the aftercoming head in breech).
  • Subgaleal haemorrhage after vacuum: a boggy scalp swelling that crosses suture lines with falling haemoglobin or shock in the newborn; an emergency.
  • Maternal risks: perineal and anal sphincter tears, haemorrhage, urinary retention and incontinence, and venous thromboembolism.
  • Failed attempt followed by caesarean with a deeply impacted head: higher risk of extension tears and haemorrhage; plan for it.
  • Shoulder dystocia is more common after assisted birth, especially with a large baby.

Next step / Follow-up

  • Before any attempt, run through the prerequisites aloud and state the plan to stop; perform a difficult or mid-cavity attempt in theatre, ready for caesarean.
  • After birth: examine the perineum and rectum for anal sphincter injury, check the bladder and assess thromboembolism risk.
  • Newborn: examine the scalp, face and head, and watch for subgaleal haemorrhage for several hours after vacuum birth.
  • Document indication, station and position, instrument, number of pulls, time and outcome; debrief the mother.
  • Refer or transfer early when the conditions are not met or no trained operator is present.

Common traps

  • If the vacuum fails, try forceps: sequential instruments greatly increase injury to the baby; it is better to move to caesarean in most cases.
  • Fully dilated means ready for instruments: the head must also be engaged and low with a known position; full dilatation alone is not enough.
  • Pulling harder will bring a stuck head: an instrument cannot overcome disproportion; no descent with a pull is a signal to stop.
  • Cephalhaematoma and subgaleal haemorrhage are the same: cephalhaematoma stays within one bone's suture lines and is benign; subgaleal bleeding spreads across sutures and can cause shock.

Test yourself

Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.

Why is an operative vaginal birth not attempted when the head is still palpable well above the pubis?

A high head means it is not engaged; the instrument cannot create room, so traction risks failure, fetal injury and a harder caesarean.

Which instrument causes more maternal anal sphincter injury, and which more neonatal scalp bleeding?

Forceps cause more severe perineal and anal sphincter tears; vacuum causes more cephalhaematoma, subgaleal haemorrhage and retinal bleeds.

Several hours after a vacuum birth the newborn has a boggy scalp swelling crossing the sutures and becomes pale and tachycardic. What is the likely diagnosis?

Subgaleal haemorrhage, bleeding beneath the scalp aponeurosis that can hold much of the baby's blood volume; it needs urgent neonatal resuscitation and transfusion.

Why is vacuum generally avoided in babies born before about 34 weeks?

The preterm scalp and skull are fragile and prone to intracranial and subgaleal bleeding under suction.

Add to my cards (4)

Elsewhere in DurgiPedia

Connections

← All of obstetrics and gynaecology

Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a doctor or your institution's protocols, and it contains no doses. For heavy bleeding, a severe headache or blurred vision, a seizure, fever, strong abdominal pain or fewer baby movements, go to an emergency department at once.

Sources: Vacuum Extraction (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Forceps Delivery (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2025); Obstetric Perineal Lacerations (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Abnormal Labor in Obstetrics: Recognition and Management (StatPearls Publishing (NCBI Bookshelf), 2025).

Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake

Representative model, for educational purposes only.