A high haemoglobin: relative, secondary or polycythaemia vera?
- Diagnostic approach
A high haemoglobin is usually the body's answer to low oxygen or a lack of water, not a cancer. Finding the cause prevents strokes and needless tests.
What it is
Polycythaemia (erythrocytosis) is a haemoglobin or haematocrit above the range for the patient's sex and altitude. It is relative when the red cell mass is normal but the plasma is reduced, secondary when erythropoietin (EPO) drives the marrow, either appropriately because tissues lack oxygen or inappropriately because a tumour or drug supplies the signal, and primary when the marrow makes red cells without being asked, as in polycythaemia vera (PV), a JAK2-driven myeloproliferative neoplasm.
Red flags
- Red flags for PV: itching after a warm bath or shower, burning red fingers and toes (erythromelalgia), a big spleen, high white cells or platelets as well, a clot in an unusual site.
- Relative: dehydration, diuretics, vomiting or diarrhoea, burns; the haematocrit falls when fluids are restored.
- Secondary from low oxygen: living at altitude, chronic lung disease, obstructive sleep apnoea, right-to-left cardiac shunts, smoking (carbon monoxide blocks haemoglobin) and high-oxygen-affinity haemoglobins.
- Secondary from a forged signal: kidney tumours and cysts, liver cancer, some brain and uterine tumours, after kidney transplantation, and testosterone or EPO given as drugs.
- PV: JAK2 V617F in about 95%, JAK2 exon 12 in most of the rest; low or low-normal EPO; often high neutrophils and platelets.
- The main danger of PV is arterial and venous thrombosis; later it can scar into myelofibrosis or turn into acute leukaemia.
The decision tree, step by step
- Confirm it: repeat the count, read it against the range for the patient's altitude, and look for a fall in plasma (dehydration, diuretics).
- Look at the other lines and the spleen: high neutrophils or platelets, or a palpable spleen, raise PV from the start.
- Measure oxygen saturation at rest; ask about smoking, snoring, daytime sleepiness, lung or heart disease and testosterone use.
- Measure serum EPO before treatment: low points to PV; normal or high points to a secondary cause.
- Low EPO or other PV clues: test JAK2 V617F, then JAK2 exon 12 if negative.
- High EPO with normal oxygen: image the kidneys and liver for a tumour or cysts.
- No cause and JAK2 negative, especially young or with a family history: think of high-affinity haemoglobin or an EPO-receptor or oxygen-sensing gene variant.
Who is ordering the red cells?
| Feature | Relative | Secondary (hypoxic) | Secondary (forged signal) | Polycythaemia vera |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red cell mass | Normal (less plasma) | High | High | High |
| EPO | Normal | Normal or high | High | Low or low-normal |
| Oxygen saturation | Normal | Low (may be low only at night) | Normal | Normal |
| White cells, platelets, spleen | Normal | Normal | Normal | Often high; spleen often large |
| Typical cause | Dehydration, diuretics | Altitude, lung disease, sleep apnoea, smoking | Kidney tumour, testosterone | JAK2 mutation |
| What fixes it | Fluids, stop the diuretic | Treat the hypoxia, stop smoking | Remove the tumour or the drug | Venesection, aspirin, cytoreduction by risk |
In clinical practice
- Bogotá sits at about 2,600 metres and many Andean towns are higher: haemoglobin is physiologically higher there, so a sea-level range overcalls polycythaemia. Use local ranges.
- Some long-term highlanders develop excessive erythrocytosis with headache, breathlessness and cyanosis (chronic mountain sickness): it is secondary, not PV, and improves with descent.
- A heavy smoker can have a high haematocrit from carbon monoxide even with a normal pulse-oximetry reading, because the oximeter reads carboxyhaemoglobin as oxygenated.
- Men on testosterone replacement need their haematocrit checked; rising values are a reason to review the treatment.
- PV treatment is by principle: venesection to bring the haematocrit down, low-dose aspirin for most, and cytoreduction (hydroxycarbamide, interferon, or a JAK inhibitor when these fail) for patients over 60 or with a previous clot.
Tests and next step
- First line: repeat count with smear, ferritin, serum EPO, oxygen saturation, kidney and liver tests.
- Low EPO or PV clues: JAK2 V617F; if negative, JAK2 exon 12; a marrow biopsy helps when JAK2 is negative or values are borderline.
- High or normal EPO: overnight oximetry or a sleep study, carboxyhaemoglobin in smokers, chest and heart assessment, kidney ultrasound.
- Ferritin matters: iron deficiency can hide PV by keeping the haemoglobin down while the red cells are small and numerous.
- A clot in the hepatic, portal or splenic veins: test JAK2 even if the counts look normal.
Common traps
- Calling every high haemoglobin at altitude, in a smoker or in sleep apnoea 'polycythaemia vera': EPO is not low in these.
- Trusting a normal daytime oxygen saturation: sleep apnoea and smoking can cause hypoxia that a single resting reading misses.
- Measuring EPO after venesection or in a patient with iron deficiency: both disturb the result.
- Missing PV because iron deficiency has pulled the haemoglobin into the normal range: a high red cell count with a low MCV is the clue.
- Giving iron to a PV patient who is iron deficient from venesection: it refuels the red cell production that venesection is trying to limit.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A patient's haematocrit is high, the EPO is low and JAK2 V617F is negative. What is the next test, and why not stop here?
Test JAK2 exon 12: a low EPO still points to a marrow-driven process, and most V617F-negative PV carries an exon 12 mutation.
Why can a heavy smoker have a high haematocrit with a normal pulse-oximetry reading?
Carbon monoxide binds haemoglobin and lowers oxygen delivery, driving EPO, but the oximeter reads carboxyhaemoglobin as oxygenated. Measure carboxyhaemoglobin.
Which finding moves a high haemoglobin away from relative polycythaemia and towards a real increase in red cells?
It persists after fluids are restored and diuretics stopped; relative polycythaemia corrects once the plasma volume is back.
What should be looked for in a patient with a high haemoglobin, high EPO and normal oxygen saturation day and night?
An EPO-producing tumour or cyst, especially in the kidney (then liver), and a history of testosterone or EPO use.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- Polycythemia: physiological causes
- Polycythaemia and polycythaemia vera
- Erythropoiesis and erythropoietin
- Living high: tissue acclimatization, highland natives and chronic mountain sickness
- Testosterone and its actions
Connections
In Pharmacology4
Educational content; it does not replace assessment by a doctor or your institution's protocols. It contains no doses.
Sources: Polycythemia vera (MedlinePlus, US National Library of Medicine, 2026); Erythropoietin test: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia (MedlinePlus, US National Library of Medicine, 2025); Chronic Mountain Sickness: Clinical Aspects, Etiology, Management, and Treatment (High Altitude Medicine & Biology (PMC), 2016); Polycythemia vera: MedlinePlus Genetics (MedlinePlus, US National Library of Medicine, 2026).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
