Aphasia: fluent or not, repeats or not
- Localization
Aphasia is a language problem, not a mouth problem. Three bedside questions tell you where in the left hemisphere the damage is.
See it in 3D: Broca's area · Wernicke's area · Frontal lobe · Temporal lobe · Parietal lobe · Insula
What it is
Aphasia is an acquired disorder of language: producing, understanding, repeating, naming, reading or writing words. It comes from damage to the language network of the dominant hemisphere, which is the left in almost all right-handers and in most left-handers. The commonest cause is a middle cerebral artery (MCA) stroke; others are tumours, head injury, encephalitis and degenerative disease (primary progressive aphasia). It is not the same as dysarthria, where the words are right but articulation is poor, or as confusion, where attention fails first and language suffers as a result.
The clues that localize
- Fluency means phrase length, effort and grammar: non-fluent speech is short, slow and telegraphic, with small grammatical words dropped.
- Test comprehension with spoken commands and yes/no questions of rising grammatical difficulty, without gestures that the patient can copy.
- Test repetition with a short sentence full of small grammatical words; failure means the perisylvian loop itself is damaged.
- Paraphasias: sound errors (phonemic) point to posterior perisylvian damage; wrong but related words (semantic) and invented words (neologisms) go with fluent aphasia.
- Reading and writing fail along with speech in aphasia; writing is normal in pure dysarthria, so ask the patient to write a sentence.
- Global aphasia (all three fail) means a large left MCA lesion with right hemiplegia; global aphasia without hemiparesis suggests separate embolic frontal and temporal lesions.
- A right upper quadrant field defect suggests a temporal lesion (Wernicke); right face and arm weakness suggests a frontal one (Broca).
How to reason, step by step
- First check attention: if the patient cannot stay on task or fluctuates, think delirium before aphasia.
- Separate dysarthria: aphasia breaks words and grammar, dysarthria slurs correct words, and writing and comprehension stay normal in dysarthria.
- Listen to spontaneous speech: fluent (normal rate and phrase length) or non-fluent (short, effortful, telegraphic).
- Test comprehension with one-, two- and three-step spoken commands and grammar-heavy yes/no questions.
- Test repetition, then naming, reading and writing.
- Combine: non-fluent with poor repetition is Broca or global; fluent with poor repetition is Wernicke or conduction; kept repetition is transcortical or anomic.
- Look for companions: right face-arm weakness (frontal), right upper quadrantanopia (temporal), apraxia, alexia.
- Use the time course: sudden means stroke (stroke code now), days with fever means encephalitis, months to years means tumour or degeneration.
Eight aphasias, three questions
| Type | Fluency | Comprehension | Repetition | Usual lesion | Companions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Broca | Non-fluent | Largely kept | Poor | Left inferior frontal gyrus (superior MCA division) | Right face and arm weakness, insight, frustration |
| Wernicke | Fluent, many wrong words | Poor | Poor | Left posterior superior temporal gyrus (inferior MCA division) | Often no weakness, poor insight, right upper quadrantanopia |
| Conduction | Fluent, sound errors | Kept | Very poor | Arcuate fasciculus, supramarginal gyrus | Repeated attempts at self-correction |
| Global | Non-fluent | Poor | Poor | Large left MCA territory | Right hemiplegia, hemisensory loss, hemianopia |
| Transcortical motor | Non-fluent | Kept | Kept | Frontal, ACA–MCA border zone | Reduced initiative, leg weakness possible |
| Transcortical sensory | Fluent | Poor | Kept, may echo | Temporo-parietal, MCA–PCA border zone | Field defect possible |
| Mixed transcortical | Non-fluent | Poor | Kept, echoes | Both border zones, sparing the loop | Severe hypoperfusion, carotid disease |
| Anomic | Fluent, word-finding pauses | Kept | Kept | Anywhere in the network; angular gyrus, temporal | Circumlocution; recovery stage or early degeneration |
In practice
- Wernicke aphasia is often triaged as confusion or psychosis: sudden fluent nonsense in an older adult is a stroke code.
- Non-fluent aphasia with right face and arm weakness is a superior division MCA stroke; look for a large vessel occlusion for thrombectomy.
- Speech and language therapy starts early and recovery continues for months; Broca and conduction aphasia often settle into anomia.
- Aphasia is not incapacity: use yes/no questions, pictures and writing, and record how decision-making capacity was assessed.
- Language loss creeping over years without a stroke suggests primary progressive aphasia, a frontotemporal or Alzheimer-type degeneration.
Next step
- Sudden aphasia: stroke pathway with non-contrast CT and CT angiography for a large vessel occlusion; MRI with diffusion when available.
- Aphasia over days with fever, seizures or behaviour change: MRI and lumbar puncture for herpes simplex encephalitis, with aciclovir started while waiting.
- Slowly progressive aphasia: MRI for focal atrophy or tumour and referral to cognitive neurology.
- Formal assessment by speech and language therapy for diagnosis, swallowing safety and rehabilitation.
- EEG if aphasia comes in brief spells, since seizures can cause transient aphasia.
Common traps
- Slurred speech is aphasia: slurring of otherwise correct words is dysarthria; aphasia shows wrong words, broken grammar or poor comprehension and also affects writing.
- A patient who speaks fluently has no serious language problem: fluent speech can be empty and full of wrong words in Wernicke aphasia, and only testing comprehension reveals it.
- Following my gesture proves comprehension: patients copy gestures and use context, so test with spoken commands alone and grammar-heavy yes/no questions.
- Sudden confused speech in an older patient is delirium: if attention is intact and onset was sudden, it may be a Wernicke-type aphasia from a stroke and needs the stroke pathway.
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
A 70-year-old suddenly speaks fluently but makes no sense, cannot follow commands and has no weakness. Relatives think he is confused. Where is the lesion and what is the next step?
Left posterior superior temporal gyrus (Wernicke aphasia), usually an inferior division MCA stroke: treat it as a stroke code with urgent CT and CT angiography, not as delirium.
A patient understands well and speaks fluently but cannot repeat a sentence and makes sound errors. Where is the lesion and why does repetition fail?
Conduction aphasia from damage to the arcuate fasciculus or supramarginal region: the receiving and speaking areas work, but the link that copies heard words into speech is cut.
After a period of severe hypotension, a patient has non-fluent speech and good comprehension but repeats sentences perfectly. Which aphasia and why is repetition spared?
Transcortical motor aphasia: a frontal border-zone (ACA–MCA) infarct lies outside the perisylvian loop, so the circuit that repeats words is intact.
Why ask a patient with slurred speech to write a sentence?
Writing uses the language network but not the speech muscles: normal writing points to dysarthria, while errors in writing point to aphasia.
Elsewhere in DurgiPedia
- The cerebral cortex and language
- Cortical syndromes: aphasia, apraxia, agnosia, neglect, frontal signs
- Mental status: consciousness, attention, memory and language
- Brain MRI: when it beats CT
- Communication disorders: language, speech sound, stuttering and social communication
- Stroke rehabilitation nursing: the weak side, shoulder, neglect, aphasia, continence and the family
Connections
See it in 3D6
The structures of Durgical's 3D anatomy where it is found.
In Pharmacology1
Educational content; it does not replace supervised training, your institution's protocols or a medical assessment. It contains no doses. For signs of stroke (face drooping, arm weakness, speech trouble), a prolonged seizure or fever with a stiff neck, call the emergency number (123 in Colombia) or go to the nearest emergency department.
Sources: Neuroanatomy, Broca Area (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Neuroanatomy, Wernicke Area (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2024); Stroke (Medical Encyclopedia) (MedlinePlus (U.S. National Library of Medicine), 2025).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.
