Unusual hernias: obturator, Spigelian, lumbar, Richter, Littre, Amyand and internal
Some hernias hide where you cannot see or feel a lump, so they first show up as a blocked or dying bowel. Knowing where to look saves the gut.
Quick facts
- Key signs
- Obturator · Spigelian · Lumbar
- Diagnosis
- CT of the abdomen and pelvis
Red flags ↓
No doses: the clinician sets them by the current guideline.
What it is
Hernias outside the common groin, umbilical and incisional types, named either by the opening they pass through (obturator canal, Spigelian aponeurosis, lumbar triangles, defects inside the abdomen) or by what they contain (part of the bowel wall in Richter, a Meckel diverticulum in Littre, the appendix in Amyand). Each is uncommon, but together they cause a large share of missed and late-diagnosed strangulations.
Who gets it
Each type is rare: obturator and Spigelian hernias make up well under 2% of abdominal wall hernias, and lumbar hernias are rarer still. Obturator hernia mainly affects thin, elderly women who have had several pregnancies, and it carries a high rate of strangulation and death because diagnosis is late. Internal hernia is one of the main late complications of laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass; with obesity and bariatric surgery rising in Colombia, emergency surgeons see it increasingly.
Causes
- Obturator: a wide obturator canal after weight loss of the protective fat pad, aging and multiple pregnancies
- Spigelian: a weak point in the aponeurosis along the semilunar line, lateral to the rectus muscle, usually near or below the arcuate line
- Lumbar: congenital weakness of the superior (Grynfeltt–Lesshaft) or inferior (Petit) lumbar triangle, or acquired after flank incisions, kidney surgery or trauma
- Richter: a small, rigid hernia neck (femoral, obturator, small port-site defects) that catches only part of the bowel wall
- Littre and Amyand: a Meckel diverticulum or the appendix happens to enter a groin hernia sac
- Internal hernia: openings in the mesentery left after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (Petersen space, the jejunojejunostomy defect) or rare congenital defects (paraduodenal, foramen of Winslow)
Risk factors
- Older age, thinness and recent weight loss
- Female sex and several pregnancies (obturator, femoral)
- Raised abdominal pressure: chronic cough, constipation, ascites, heavy lifting
- Previous abdominal or flank surgery and laparoscopic port sites
- Roux-en-Y gastric bypass, especially with rapid weight loss and mesenteric defects left open
- Connective tissue weakness and smoking
Pathophysiology
A weak spot or abnormal opening with a narrow, firm edge → bowel slides in, often without a visible bulge because the opening is deep, between muscle layers or inside the abdomen → the neck squeezes the veins before the arteries → the trapped bowel swells, which tightens the neck further → arterial inflow stops → ischaemia, necrosis and perforation → peritonitis and sepsis. Because nothing is seen early, diagnosis waits for obstruction or peritonitis, which is why these hernias strangulate more often than common ones. In a Richter hernia only part of the wall is caught, so the lumen stays open and the bowel can die without obstruction.
Classification
- By opening, abdominal wall: obturator (through the obturator canal of the pelvis), Spigelian (semilunar line), lumbar (superior or inferior triangle; congenital, acquired or incisional)
- By opening, inside the abdomen (internal hernia): after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (Petersen space, jejunojejunostomy defect, mesocolic window) or congenital (paraduodenal, foramen of Winslow, transmesenteric)
- By content: Richter (part of the antimesenteric bowel wall), Littre (Meckel diverticulum), Amyand (appendix in an inguinal hernia), de Garengeot (appendix in a femoral hernia)
- By state: reducible, incarcerated or strangulated
Symptoms and signs
- Obturator: intermittent or complete small bowel obstruction in a thin older woman, often with no lump; pain along the inner thigh to the knee, worse on hip extension and rotation (Howship–Romberg sign)
- Spigelian: localised pain or a soft lump lateral to the lower rectus, often felt only when the patient strains; frequently impalpable
- Lumbar: a soft flank bulge above the iliac crest that grows on standing or coughing, with back or flank discomfort
- Richter: a small, tender groin or port-site lump with pain and fever but little or no vomiting or distension
- Internal hernia after gastric bypass: recurrent colicky upper or left abdominal pain after meals, sometimes with nausea, in a patient who has lost a lot of weight
- Littre and Amyand: an irreducible tender groin hernia, sometimes with signs of appendicitis or diverticulitis inside it
Diagnosis
- Clinical
- Look for the hole when there is no lump: examine both groins, the semilunar lines and the flanks with the patient standing and straining, test for the Howship–Romberg sign, and ask about previous surgery, especially gastric bypass. A vaginal or rectal examination can occasionally feel an obturator hernia.
- Tests
- Full blood count, electrolytes, creatinine and lactate; these are often normal early, so normal results do not exclude strangulation.
- Imaging
- CT of the abdomen and pelvis is the key test: it shows bowel between the pectineus and obturator externus muscles (obturator), a sac beneath the external oblique aponeurosis (Spigelian), a flank defect (lumbar) and, after gastric bypass, a swirl of mesenteric vessels with clustered loops (internal hernia). Ultrasound with straining can show Spigelian and lumbar hernias. A normal CT does not exclude an intermittent internal hernia.
Differential diagnosis
- Adhesive small bowel obstruction
- Femoral or inguinal hernia
- Hip or knee osteoarthritis, or nerve root pain (for obturator thigh pain)
- Abdominal wall haematoma, lipoma or tumour (for Spigelian and lumbar lumps)
- Acute appendicitis or Meckel diverticulitis outside a hernia
- Marginal ulcer, gallstones or intussusception after gastric bypass
Unusual hernias: where the hole is and how they show
| Hernia | Where the hole is | Typical patient and picture | Key clue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Obturator | Obturator canal of the pelvis, under the pectineus | Thin elderly woman with small bowel obstruction and no lump | Inner thigh or knee pain on hip movement (Howship–Romberg); CT |
| Spigelian | Semilunar line, lateral edge of the lower rectus | Localised lower abdominal pain, lump only on straining | Lies under the external oblique aponeurosis; ultrasound or CT |
| Lumbar | Superior or inferior lumbar triangle of the flank | Flank bulge, often after kidney or flank surgery | Grows on standing and coughing; usually wide neck |
| Richter | Any small, tight neck (femoral, obturator, port site) | Tender small lump, patient ill but still passing stool and gas | Strangulation without obstruction |
| Littre | Usually a groin or umbilical hernia | Irreducible tender hernia | Sac contains a Meckel diverticulum |
| Amyand | Inguinal hernia (femoral: de Garengeot) | Right groin hernia, may look like a strangulated one | Sac contains the appendix, sometimes inflamed |
| Internal hernia after gastric bypass | Mesenteric defects: Petersen space, jejunojejunostomy | Recurrent postprandial pain after large weight loss | Mesenteric swirl on CT; low threshold for laparoscopy |
| Femoral hernia (for contrast) | Femoral canal, below the inguinal ligament | Older woman with a small lump below and lateral to the pubic tubercle | High strangulation risk; often Richter type |
Goal of treatment
Recognise the hernia before the bowel dies, release and inspect the trapped bowel, remove any non-viable segment, and close the opening so it does not recur.
Treatment
- Acute
- Suspected strangulation or obstruction: intravenous fluids, nil by mouth, nasogastric decompression, analgesia, antibiotics when bowel is compromised, and emergency surgery without delay for imaging that would not change the plan.
- Surgical
- Obturator hernia: emergency laparoscopic or open (lower midline or preperitoneal) reduction, resection of non-viable bowel, and closure of the obturator canal with sutures or mesh; the other side is checked because they are often bilateral.
- Surgical
- Spigelian and lumbar hernias: elective repair, open or laparoscopic, usually with mesh; Spigelian hernias are repaired soon after diagnosis because their narrow neck often incarcerates.
- Surgical
- Richter, Littre and Amyand hernias: repair of the hernia with inspection of the trapped tissue; resection of a necrotic bowel segment or an inflamed Meckel diverticulum, appendicectomy when the appendix is inflamed, and avoidance of mesh in a contaminated field.
- Surgical
- Internal hernia after gastric bypass: urgent diagnostic laparoscopy when clinically suspected, reduction of the loops and closure of all mesenteric defects; closing these defects at the original bypass reduces the risk.
- Follow-up
- After emergency repair: watch for ongoing ileus, anastomotic leak and wound infection; check viability of bowel left in place if there was doubt (second-look operation).
Complications
- Incarceration and strangulation
- Bowel necrosis, perforation and peritonitis
- Short bowel syndrome after extensive resection (internal hernia with volvulus)
- Obturator nerve injury or persistent thigh pain
- Mesh infection, recurrence and chronic pain
- Death, especially in elderly patients with late diagnosis
Common traps
- No lump means no hernia: obturator, Spigelian and internal hernias are often invisible; in a thin older woman with bowel obstruction and no scars, look for an obturator hernia on CT
- A strangulated hernia always obstructs the bowel: in a Richter hernia only part of the wall is trapped, so the bowel can die while stool and gas still pass
- Knee or inner-thigh pain in an elderly woman who is vomiting is just arthritis: pain down the medial thigh on hip movement can be the obturator nerve squeezed by a hernia
- Normal blood tests and a normal CT rule out internal hernia after gastric bypass: it is often intermittent and can look normal between attacks; recurrent pain after meals warrants diagnostic laparoscopy
- Every appendix found in a hernia sac must come out: a normal appendix in an Amyand hernia is often left, while an inflamed one is removed and mesh is avoided if there is contamination
Prognosis
Elective repair has good results and low recurrence. Outcome in emergencies depends on how long the bowel was trapped: late-diagnosed obturator and internal hernias carry high rates of bowel resection and death, while early recognition and surgery usually give full recovery.
Prevention
- Suspect a hidden hernia in every bowel obstruction without a previous operation
- Close mesenteric defects during Roux-en-Y gastric bypass
- Repair Spigelian and femoral hernias electively once found
- Teach patients after gastric bypass to seek care quickly for recurrent abdominal pain
Test yourself
Think of the answer, then tap the question to see it.
An 84-year-old thin woman with no previous surgery has vomiting, distension and pain on the inside of her right knee. Which hernia do you suspect and how do you confirm it?
Obturator hernia pressing on the obturator nerve (Howship–Romberg sign). CT of the abdomen and pelvis shows bowel between the pectineus and obturator externus; she needs urgent surgery.
Why can a Richter hernia become gangrenous without causing bowel obstruction?
Only part of the antimesenteric wall is caught in the neck, so the lumen stays open while the trapped part loses its blood supply and can perforate.
Why is a Spigelian hernia easy to miss on examination?
It usually lies beneath the intact external oblique aponeurosis, spreading between muscle layers rather than bulging under the skin; ultrasound or CT with straining shows it.
A woman 18 months after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass has bouts of colicky upper abdominal pain after meals. What is the concern, and why does weight loss raise the risk?
Internal hernia through Petersen space or the jejunojejunostomy defect. Loss of mesenteric fat widens these openings so loops slip through and twist; get a CT and keep a low threshold for laparoscopy.
What does the sac contain in a Littre hernia and in an Amyand hernia?
Littre: a Meckel diverticulum. Amyand: the appendix inside an inguinal hernia; the appendix in a femoral hernia is called a de Garengeot hernia.
Why it happens
Connections
Educational information, not medical advice. For any symptom, see a health professional.
Sources: Obturator Hernia (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2025); Spigelian Hernia (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Richter Hernia (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2026); Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass Chronic Complications (StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf), 2023); Hernia (MedlinePlus (U.S. National Library of Medicine), 2025).
Spotted a mistake?We are always improving for the community. Tell us what is wrong and our team will review it.Report a mistake
Representative model, for educational purposes only.

